Reflex Theory, Cautionary Tale Misleading Simplicity in Early Neuroscience
Main Article Content
Abstract
This paper takes an integrated history and philosophy of science approach to the topic of "simplicity out of complexity". The reflex theory was a framework within early 20th century psychology and neuroscience which aimed to decompose complex behaviours and neural responses into simple reflexes. It was controversial in its time, and did not live up to its own theoretical and empirical ambitions. Examination of this episode poses important questions about the limitations of simplifying strategies, and the relationship between simplification and the engineering approach to biology.
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
References
Barack, David L., and John W. Krakauer. 2021. "Two views on the cognitive brain." Nature Reviews Neuroscience https://doi-org.ezproxy.is.ed.ac.uk/10.1038/s41583-021-00448-6.
Bechtel, William, and Robert C. Richardson. 2010. Discovering Complexity. 2nd ed. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Breland, Keller, and Marian Breland. 1961. "The Misbehavior of Organisms." American Psychologist 16:681-684.
Bridgman, P. W. 1927. The Logic of Modern Physics. New York: MacMillan.
Buckley, Kerry W. 1989. Mechanical Man: John B. Watson and the Beginnings of Behaviorism. New York: The Guilford Press.
Burnston, Daniel. 2020. "Getting over Atomism: Functional Decomposition in Complex Neural Systems." British Journal for the Philosophy of Science. doi: 10.1093/bjps/axz039.
Buytendijk, F. J. J., and H. Plessner. 1936. "Die Physiologische Erklärung des Verhaltens: Eine Kritik an der Theorie Pawlows." Acta Biotheoretica 1:151–172.
Canguilhem, Georges. 1965/2008. "The Living and Its Milieu." In Knowledge of Life, edited by Paola Marrati and Todd Meyers, 98-120. New York: Fordham University Press.
Canguilhem, Georges. 1994. "The Concept of Reflex." In A Vital Rationalist: Selected Writings from Georges Canguilhem, edited by François Delaporte. New York: Zone Books.
Casper, Stephen T. 2014. "History and Neuroscience: An Integrative Legacy." Isis 105:123-132.
Clarke, Edwin, and L. S. Jacyna. 1987. Nineteenth-Century Origins of Neuroscientific Concepts. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Dewey, John. 1896. "The Reflex Arc Concept in Psychology." The Psychological Review 3 (4):357-370.
Dupré, John. 2012. "It is not Possible to Reduce Biological Explanations to Explanations in Chemistry and/or Physics." In Processes of Life: Essays in the Philosophy of Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Falkenburg, Brigette. 2019. "Mechanistic Explanations Generalized: How Far Can We Go." In Mechanistic Explanations in Physics and Beyond, edited by Brigette Falkenburg and Gregor Schiemann, 65-90. Berlin: Springer.
Fearing, Franklin. 1930. Reflex Action: A Study in the History of Physiological Psychology. New York: Hafner Publishing Company.
Goldstein, K. 1934/1939. The Organism: A Holistic Approach to Biology Derived from Pathological Data in Man. New York: American Book Company.
Graham Brown, Thomas. 1914. "On the nature of the fundamental activity of the nervous centres; together with an analysis of the conditioning of rhythmic activity in progression, and a theory of the evolution of function in the nervous system." Journal of Physiology 48:18-46.
Harrington, A. 1996. Reenchanted Science: Holism in German Culture from Wilhelm II to Hitler. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Hough, Theodore. 1915. "The Classification of Nervous Reactions." Science 41 (1055):407-418.
Hull, Clark, and H. D. Baernstein. 1929. "A Mechanical Parallel to the Conditioned Reflex." Science 70 (1801):14-15.
Jennings, Herbert Spencer. 1906. Behavior of the lower organisms. New York: Columbia University Press.
Lashley, Karl S. 1931. "Cerebral Control versus Reflexology: A Reply to Professor Hunter." Journal of general psychology. 5:3-19.
Levy, Arnon. 2018. "Idealization and abstraction: refining the distinction." Synthese. doi: https://doi.org/10.1007/s11229-018-1721-z.
Loeb, J. 1900. Comparative Physiology of the Brain and Comparative Psychology. New York: J. P. Putnam’s sons.
Loeb, J. 1912. The Mechanistic Conception of Life. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
Mach, Ernst. 1883/1919. The Science of Mechanics. Translated by Thomas J. McCormack. Chicago, IL: Open Court.
Mach, Ernst. 1886/1914. The analysis of sensations, and the relation of the physical to the psychical. Translated by C. M. Williams. Chicago, IL: Open Court.
Merleau-Ponty, Maurice. 1942/1967. The Structure of Behaviour. Translated by Alden L. Fisher. Boston: Beacon Press.
Moinat, Frédéric. 2012. Le vivant et sa naturalisation: Le problème du naturalisme en biologie chez Husserl et le jeune Merleau-Ponty, Phaenomenologica. Dordrecht: Springer.
Moore, J. 2005. "Some Historical and Conceptual Background to the Development of B.F. Skinner’s ‘Radical Behaviorism’ — Part 2." Journal of Mind and Behavior 26 (1-2):95-124.
Musall, Simon, Anne E Urai, David Sussillo, and Anne K Churchland. 2019. "Harnessing behavioral diversity to understand neural computations for cognition." Current Opinion in Neurobiology 58:229–238.
Nastase, Samuel A., Ariel Goldstein, and Uri Hasson. 2020. "Keep it real: rethinking the primacy of experimental control in cognitive neuroscience." NeuroImage 222:117254.
Nutt, David, and Anna Need. 2014. "Where now for schizophrenia research?" European Neuropsychopharmacology 24:1181–1187.
Pauly, Philip. 1987. Controlling Life: Jacques Loeb & the Engineering Ideal in Biology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pavlov, Ivan. 1927/1960. Conditioned Reflexes: An Investigation of the Physiological Activity of the Cerebral Cortex. New York: Dover Publications Inc.
Ramsden, Edmund. forthcoming. "Behavioral Engineering and the Problems of Animal Misbehavior." In Nature Remade: Engineering Life, Envisioning Worlds, edited by Luis Campos, Michael R. Dietrich, Tiago Saraiva and Christian C. Young. Chicago, IL: Chicago University Press.
Sherrington, C. S. 1906. The Integrative Action of the Nervous System. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons.
Sherrington, C. S. 1909. "A Mammalian Spinal Preparation." Journal of Physiology 38 (5):375–383.
Skinner, B. F. 1931/1961. "The Concept of the Reflex in the Description of Behavior." In Cumulative Record, edited by B. F. Skinner. East Norwalk, CT: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B. F. 1947/1961. "Current Trends in Experimental Psychology." In Cumulative Record, edited by B. F. Skinner. East Norwalk, CT: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B. F. 1972. Cumulative Record. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.
Skinner, B. F., and W. J. Crozier. 1931. "Review of ‘Reflex Action, a Study in the History of Physiological Psychology’." Journal of general psychology 5:125-129.
Smith, Laurence D. 1995. "Inquiry nearer the source: Bacon, Mach, and The Behavior of Organisms. In (Eds.), ." In Modern Perspectives on B. F. Skinner and contemporary behaviorism, edited by J. T. Todd and E. K. Morris, 39-50. Westport, CT: Greenwood Press.
Smith, Laurence D. 1996. "Knowledge as Power: The Baconian Roots of Skinner’s Social Meliorism." In B. F. Skinner and Behaviorism in American Culture, edited by Laurence D. Smith and William Ray Woodward. Bethlehem: Lehigh University Press.
Smith, Roger. 1973. "The Background of Physiological Psychology in Natural Philosophy." History of Science 11:75-123.
Smith, Roger. 1992. Inhibition: History and Meaning in the Sciences of Mind and Brain. Berkeley: University of California Press.
Todes, Daniel P. 2014. Ivan Pavlov : A Russian Life in Science. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Watson, John B. 1913. "Psychology as the Behaviorist Views it." Psychological Review 20 (2):158–177.