<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.1 20151215//EN" "https://jats.nlm.nih.gov/archiving/1.1/JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article dtd-version="1.1" article-type="book-review" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
    <front>
        <journal-meta>
            <journal-id>TMR</journal-id>
            <journal-title-group>
                <journal-title>The Medieval Review</journal-title>
            </journal-title-group>
            <issn pub-type="epub">1096-746X</issn>
            <publisher>
                <publisher-name>Indiana University</publisher-name>
            </publisher>
        </journal-meta>
        <article-meta>
            <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">24.10.17</article-id>
            <title-group>
                <article-title>24.10.17, Cook, Astralabe</article-title>
            </title-group>
            <contrib-group>
                <contrib contrib-type="author">
                    <name>
                        <surname>Constant Mews</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                    <aff>Monash University</aff>
                    <address>
                        <email>Constant.Mews@monash.edu</email>
                    </address>
                </contrib>
            </contrib-group>
            <pub-date publication-format="epub" date-type="pub" iso-8601-date="2022">
                <year>2024</year>
            </pub-date>
            <product product-type="book">
                <person-group>
                    <name>
                        <surname>Cook, Brenda M</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                </person-group>
                <source>Astralabe: The Life and Times of the Son of Heloise and Abelard</source>
                <series>The New Middle Ages</series>
                <year iso-8601-date="2023">2023</year>
                <publisher-loc>Cham, Switzerland</publisher-loc>
                <publisher-name>Palgrave Macmillan</publisher-name>
                <page-range>Pp. xxvi, 429</page-range>
                <price>$129.99 (hardback)</price>
                <isbn>978-3-031-32087-3</isbn>
            </product>
            <permissions>
                <copyright-statement>Copyright 2024 Trustees of Indiana University. Indiana University provides the information contained in this file for non-commercial, personal, or research use only. All other use, including but not limited to commercial or scholarly reproductions, redistribution, publication or transmission, whether by electronic means or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited.</copyright-statement>
            </permissions>
        </article-meta>
    </front>
    <body>
        <p>How does one escape celebrity parents? This was the challenge faced by Astralabe, forever
            remembered as the offspring of an illicit love affair, reported in detail by Peter
            Abelard in the <italic>Historia calamitatum</italic>. Most accounts of his relationship
            with Heloise mention their child only in passing. The most that might be said is that
            Abelard composed for his instruction the <italic>Carmen ad Astralabium</italic>, a
            didactic poem recently re-edited and translated by Juanita Feros Ruys within <italic>The
                Repentant Abelard. Family, Gender and Ethics in Peter Abelard’s “Carmen ad
                Astralabium” and “Planctus,” </italic>published in 2014 in the same series as this
            new volume by Brenda M. Cook. This neglect makes it all the more remarkable that Brenda
            Cook should produce a volume of over four hundred pages about a figure known through
            only a few details. Apart from scattered references by Abelard, Heloise, and Peter the
            Venerable, we know only from a charter of the Cistercian abbey of Busay (also known as
            Buzay) that a canon of Nantes was called Astralabe, and that an Astralabe is recorded as
            the fourth abbot of Hauterive, a Cistercian abbey near Fribourg in Switzerland, between
            1162 and 1165. The only other twelfth-century allusion to that name occurs within a
            fable included within the Middle High German <italic>Kaiserchronik</italic>, from
            mid-twelfth-century Regensberg in which a certain <italic>Astrolabius</italic> has to be
            saved from falling in love with a statue of Venus--an episode that Cook convincingly
            argues adapts a familiar story so as to allude to Abelard’s being caught by lust for
            Heloise. Cook’s major focus, however, is on the way Astralabe’s career was shaped by
            dynastic politics in the region of Nantes and Brittany as well as by the dramatic
            expansion of the Cistercian Order across Europe during these decades.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>It might seem counter-intuitive to think that the child of Abelard and Heloise should
            have chosen to join the Cistercian Order, given the known hostility of Bernard of
            Clairvaux to the peripatetic of Le Pallet. Cook’s monograph is important for helping us
            to break down artificial divisions between admirers and critics of the Cistercian Order.
            The limitations of the surviving evidence are such that it is often easier for a
            novelist to imagine what might have happened than for a historian to confine herself to
            what can be said, with prudent recognition of what might be possible. With a remarkable
            command of twelfth-century regional politics, Cook walks a fine line between these two
            extremes.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>The first part of Cook’s monograph deals with the frequently re-told story of the affair
            of Abelard and Heloise. She observes that the name Heloise chose for her child, an
            instrument for observing the heavens, itself reflects their fondness for celestial
            learning. Less convincing is her suggestion, based on an unsubstantiated claim made by
            Papire Masson in the sixteenth century, that Heloise might have been the daughter of an
            otherwise unidentified canon of Notre-Dame called John. Yet she also acknowledges
            another possibility, raised by Werner Robl from a coincidence of death-dates, that
            Heloise’s mother, Hersende, was the same person as the Hersende of Champagne (related to
            the Montmorency family, guardians of Argenteuil), as helped Robert of Arbrissel
            establish the abbey of Fontevraud on her property.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Cook’s analysis becomes firmer when she examines the borderland character of Le Pallet
            and the Nantais region on the border between Brittany and the Poitou, from which
            Abelard’s family (of mixed Poitevin and Breton background) came and within which the
            young Astralabe was raised. She rightly observes Abelard’s strong links to his family,
            illustrated by his dedicating the <italic>Dialectica </italic>for the education of the
            sons of his brother, Dagobert (written more likely around when he had returned to his
            home regions c.1112/13 than c.1123, as claimed by Cook at 75 and 95). She picks up on
            the coincidence that Abelard’s father and then mother chose to enter religious life in
            1112 at the same time as the Duke of Brittany, Alain IV Fergant (c.1063-1119) became a
            monk at Redon. His wife, the formidable Ermengard of Anjou (c.1068-1147), was never
            formally enclosed as a nun, but became a major patron of religious reform through her
            support of Robert of Arbrissel at Fontevraud, and subsequently of various Cistercian
            foundations in the region. She may well have influenced Abelard’s appointment to St
            Gildas c. 1127, a position he technically held until his death in 1142, even if in
            practice he had abandoned the abbey by the early 1130s. One of Ermengard’s foundations
            was Busay (Buzay), founded by Bernard of Clairvaux in 1135 at her request. Cook unravels
            the significance of a charter of that abbey (where Bernard’s brother, Nivard, was prior)
            that mentions both Astralabe and his uncle, Porchaire (a Poitevin name), who was a canon
            of Nantes, but became a monk at Busay, probably after Bernard’s second visit to Nantes
            in 1143. She suggests that Astralabe was groomed by his uncle to take over his canonry
            at the cathedral, possibly becoming its precentor.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Cook’s analysis of the foundation of Busay helps explain not just the subsequent
            evolution of Astralabe’s career, but also Abelard’s detailed knowledge of Cistercian
            liturgical reforms, evident in a harshly critical letter that he sent to Bernard of
            Clairvaux after the abbot had visited Heloise at the Paraclete. Abelard and Heloise may
            have been critical of individual Cistercian practices, but they shared with the
            Cistercians a common interest in retrieving authenticity in monastic observance. This is
            illustrated by the fact, uncovered by the late Chrysogonus Waddell, that the Paraclete
            liturgy combined Cistercian hymns and practices with those devised by Abelard. Cook’s
            emphasis on Abelard’s brother becoming a monk in the 1140s at Busay (where Bernard’s
            brother was prior) provides another avenue through which Abelard and Heloise could have
            learned about Cistercian practice. </p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Cook also offers a way of understanding what might seem to be the most enigmatic aspect
            of Astralabe’s career, namely his decision to become a monk at Cherlieu, the motherhouse
            of Hauterive, where he would become its fourth abbot between 1162 and 1165. We know from
            a letter of Peter the Venerable that in around 1143 that Heloise wanted Astralabe to
            find a position closer to the Paraclete. This did not happen. Cook suggests that
            Astralabe’s familiarity with Cistercian practice would have been encouraged not just by
            Porchaire, but by Bernard of Escoublac, a former dean of the cathedral who became a monk
            at Clairvaux before becoming bishop of Nantes between 1147 and 1169. She also argues
            that Astralabe’s decision to leave Nantes may have been encouraged by the rebellion of
            the city, encouraged by its bishop, against the authority of Count Hoël and its shifting
            loyalty to Henry II, duke of Anjou and king of England. She argues that these events
            prompted Astralabe’s decision to leave Nantes and become a monk in a far distant abbey.
            Her analysis of the documentation from Hauterive about their fourth abbot, with this
            unusual name, is meticulous. Given the close personal connections between Nantes,
            Clairvaux, and Busay, it is quite possible that Astralabe chose to become a monk at
            Cherlieu at the invitation of Guy, its abbot between 1131 and 1158. She suggests that
            their common ground was music. Guy had been entrusted by Bernard of Clairvaux with
            reforming Cistercian chant within the Order during the 1140s. Through these connections,
            Astralabe somehow made contact with the Abbot of Cherlieu, and came to that abbey before
            going to its daughter house in Hauterive.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Perhaps the one detail in Cook’s argument where specialists may disagree relates to the
            identity of the abbot with whom Astralabe must have made contact: Guy, a monk of
            Clairvaux, who became abbot of Cherlieu 1131-58 and was the leading theorist of chant in
            the Cistercian Order. While Cook accepts a nineteenth-century claim that the Abbot of
            Cherlieu was from a Burgundian family (of Durnes), Claire Maître finds no support for
            this in her meticulous 1995 study of Guy’s <italic>Regulae de arte musica</italic>.
            Dismissing Guy’s link to Durnes clears the way for identifying the Abbot of Cherlieu
            with Guy of Eu (Guido Augensis), identified in the Cistercian <italic>Tonale </italic>as
            author of these <italic>Regulae</italic>. Guy exerted huge influence across the Order
            through his teaching on chant. (A small detail, not mentioned by Cook, that provides
            further evidence for a connection between Abelard and Cistercian chant is that Guy
            introduced the term <italic>maneriae </italic>to describe four core types of chant, a
            neologism that Abelard uses in his dialectic to refer to a subset of species.) Not the
            least intriguing part of Cook’s analysis is that she introduces into her story the
            discovery that the earliest surviving copy of the Cistercian Antiphonary, along with
            introductions by Bernard and Guy was produced at Hauterive in the early 1160s, precisely
            when Astralabe was its abbot. David Wulstan edits that manuscript, now at Mount Melleray
            in Ireland, in <italic>The Letter of St. Bernard and The Tract on the Cistercian
                Revision of the Antiphoner</italic> (Lion’s Bay: Institute of Medieval Music, 2015),
            suggesting that Astralabe might have been involved in transmitting its teaching. While
            Cook does not get involved in musicological issues, she raises the intriguing
            possibility that it was through interest in music (and perhaps the suggestion of
            Heloise) that Astralabe, familiar with Cistercian chant through Busay and Nantes,
            decided to join Guy at Cherlieu. From there, he joined a daughter foundation at
            Hauterive rising quickly to the rank of abbot. This would have been not long after
            Bernard’s death in 1153, when tensions had subsided. Becoming a Cistercian at Cherlieu
            and then Hauterive was his way of escaping his father’s reputation.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Inevitably, the limitations of the surviving evidence mean that any historian can only
            propose what might seem a plausible way of explaining the evidence. Cook recognises that
            she is raising hypotheses about Astralabe’s career to explain the surviving evidence
            without being able to arrive at certainty on any of these issues. Nonetheless, she
            deserves to be congratulated for bringing to wider attention an unjustly neglected
            aspect of the story of Abelard and Heloise. In the process she tells us much of value
            both about regional tensions in the region of Nantes and about the expansion of the
            Cistercian Order in the twelfth century.</p>
        <p> </p>
    </body>
</article>