<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.1 20151215//EN" "https://jats.nlm.nih.gov/archiving/1.1/JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article dtd-version="1.1" article-type="book-review" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
    <front>
        <journal-meta>
            <journal-id>TMR</journal-id>
            <journal-title-group>
                <journal-title>The Medieval Review</journal-title>
            </journal-title-group>
            <issn pub-type="epub">1096-746X</issn>
            <publisher>
                <publisher-name>Indiana University</publisher-name>
            </publisher>
        </journal-meta>
        <article-meta>
            <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">24.10.13</article-id>
            <title-group>
                <article-title>24.10.13, Counet (ed), A Question of Life and Death. Living and Dying in Medieval Philosophy</article-title>
            </title-group>
            <contrib-group>
                <contrib contrib-type="author">
                    <name>
                        <surname>Jessica Barr</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                    <aff>        University of Massachusetts Amherst
                    </aff>
                    <address>
                        <email>jbarr@umass.edu</email>
                    </address>
                </contrib>
            </contrib-group>
            <pub-date publication-format="epub" date-type="pub" iso-8601-date="2022">
                <year>2024</year>
            </pub-date>
            <product product-type="book">
                <person-group>
                    <name>
                        <surname>Counet, Jean-Michel (ed)</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                </person-group>
                <source>A Question of Life and Death. Living and Dying in Medieval Philosophy: Acts
                    of the XXIII Annual Colloquium of the Société Internationale pour l’Étude de la
                    Philosophie Médiévale, Leuven, 11–12 October 2018</source>
                <series>Rencontres de Philosophie Médiévale</series>
                <year iso-8601-date="2022">2022</year>
                <publisher-loc>Turnhout, Belgium</publisher-loc>
                <publisher-name>Brepols</publisher-name>
                <page-range>Pp. 222</page-range>
                <price>€ 60.00 (hardback)</price>
                <isbn>978-2-503-60059-8</isbn>
            </product>
            <permissions>
                <copyright-statement>Copyright 2024 Trustees of Indiana University. Indiana University provides the information contained in this file for non-commercial, personal, or research use only. All other use, including but not limited to commercial or scholarly reproductions, redistribution, publication or transmission, whether by electronic means or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited.</copyright-statement>
            </permissions>
        </article-meta>
    </front>
    <body>
        <p>This collection is published in memory of Pieter De Leemans, who passed away in 2019 and
            who organized the colloquium that led to this volume. An expert on the medieval Latin
            translations of Aristotle’s texts, his impact on the field was great, and a short
            tribute that prefaces the volume testifies to his work as a scholar, teacher, and
            colleague.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Each of this collection’s nine essays takes up quite specific aspects of medieval
            scholastic theology pertaining to life, death, and the soul and elaborates them through
            consideration of the different ways in which mostly thirteenth-century commentators,
            theologians, and authors responded to them. They thus impart a strong sense of the
            lively atmosphere of engaged debate that was prevalent in medieval philosophy.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>While the topics of the essays vary, there are a number of overlapping themes, topics,
            and questions: for example, two essays deal with the question of radical moisture and
            its relationship to the prolongation of life, and commentaries on the Nicomachean Ethics
            are the subject of two other essays. The collection as a whole is concerned with
            questions such as the following: What is the (good) life of the soul, and how does it
            relate to life in God? Can the soul ever know itself in this life? Are the dying happy?
            Is death ever preferable to life? Can life be prolonged through humoral manipulation?
            What is life? And how do scientific theories interact with theology in understanding
            life, death, and the resurrection of the body? Essays that deal with related questions
            are grouped together in the collection, although there are no explicit indicators of
            these connections (other than their titles). Below, I have briefly summarized each essay
            in relation to some of the other themes that I saw emerging in terms of methodology,
            rather than subject.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Questions of genre and disciplines are important to the collection. Violeta Cervera
            Nero’s contribution, for example, puts into dialogue “didascalic” texts, such as guides
            for students and compendia, and commentaries dating from the 1230s to explore how these
            two types of text conceive of the divisions among the different branches of philosophy
            in relation to the life of the soul. Aristotle’s <italic>Nicomachean Ethics
            </italic>were introduced into the curriculum at the University of Paris in 1215, and the
            compendia and student guides associated with it provide useful information regarding how
            it was taught. The <italic>Guide for Students</italic> that Nero considers, for
            instance, divides philosophy quite differently from Arnoul of Provence’s tripartite
            division of life in oneself (ethics), in one’s family (economics), and in the broader
            community (politics), focusing instead on the life of the soul in God. Also interested
            in how teaching texts are conceptually distinct from other philosophical genres is Tilke
            Nelis, who analyzes the differences between a short, anonymous compendium of <italic>De
                Longitudine et Brevitate Vitae</italic> (from Ms. Tanner 116), the full Greek text,
            and the text’s Latin translation to explore the generic characteristics of compendia
            that were intended for teaching. Many of the features of the compendium reflect its
            genre as a summary or <italic>abbreviatio</italic>; it is consistently more condensed
            than the Aristotelian text in Greek or the Latin <italic>translatio vetus</italic> by
            James of Venice, omitting, for instance, certain examples and shortening repeated
            phrases. The compendium also adds clear chapter headings and each of its four chapters
            is introduced by a summary of its contents. Again, this is appropriate to its genre. The
            essay also includes a source study and an edition of the Tanner manuscript. </p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>One of the particularly interesting things about this collection is how it illuminates
            the intersections of disciplinary boundaries as well as generic ones, demonstrating how
            medical and scientific theories could be brought to bear on theology. Julien Lambinet,
            for instance, explains how Alexander of Hales uses contemporary physiological theories
            to address the question of whether the human body is both corruptible and incorruptible.
            Hales is responding to the passage in Peter Lombard’s<italic>Sentences</italic> which
            discusses Adam’s loss of immortality after the Fall. Hales’s contribution is to consider
            how Galen’s theories of radical and nutrimental moisture play into the duality of
            corruptibility and incorruptibility that characterize the first humans. Chiara
            Crisciani’s essay takes up Albertus Magnus’s claim that only physicians should opine on
            whether manipulating radical moisture can prolong life indefinitely, exploring how a
            physician’s commentary, Tommaso del Garbo’s fourteenth-century
                <italic>Tractatus</italic>, compares to those of the philosophers Arnold de
            Villanova and Pietro d’Abano. The question of how and whether life can be prolonged in
            this way is also taken up by Marek Gensler and Monika Mansfeld, who focus on Walter
            Burley’s commentaries on the <italic>Parva naturalia</italic>. (Spoiler alert: It
            can’t.)</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>The use of mathematical argumentation is the subject of Chris Schabeland Monica Brînzei’s
            essay, which discusses a set of <italic>principia</italic> (a genre in which bachelors
            of the <italic>Sentences</italic> at the University of Paris would take turns defending
            a thesis that they had preciously circulated to the others) that consider whether it is
            ever rational--or even possible--to choose annihilation over suffering. The authors
            demonstrate how Jean de Mirecourt and Pierre Ceffons use mathematical argumentation and
            the related concepts of limits and latitudes to push their opponents’ views to an absurd
            conclusion in support of their thesis that that annihilation can be the reasonable
            choice when the other option is extreme and prolonged suffering. </p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>Of course, theological responses to Aristotelian arguments regarding life and death are a
            dominant theme of the collection. Valeria A. Buffon uses commentaries on a passage from
            Aristotle’s analysis of Solon’s adage that no man can be called happy until he is dead
            to discuss the variety of ways in which thirteenth-century commentators interpreted the
            relationships among happiness, life, and death, arguing that scholars tended to view
            these issues according to their philosophical and faith-based commitments. Sylvia Negri
            discusses Henry of Ghent’s argument that the will is ultimately ontologically superior
            to the intellect and that it is the ultimate determinant of the degree to which any
            being can be said to live. Free choice, or <italic>liberum arbitrium</italic>, is at its
            greatest when the agent is moved by no interest or influence outside of self, meaning
            that there is a scale of “life” that ranges from plants at the very bottom, through
            animals, humans, and angels, to God, who moves and wills only what he already is, at the
            peak. Finally, Jean-Michel Counet concludes the collection with a reflection on why,
            according to Aquinas, the soul in this life cannot have intuitive knowledge of itself.
            Counet proposes a hypothesis concerning how the soul is received into the body in this
            life but the body is received into the soul in the resurrection as a possible
            explanation for why the soul’s knowledge is limited before death but not when it is
            within the resurrected body; he concludes by considering why Thomas in fact did
                <italic>not</italic> use this reasoning to explain the soul’s lack of intuitive
            knowledge of itself.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>This volume will be of interest to scholars of medieval philosophy who are particularly
            interested in questions of the body/soul relationship and--as the title suggests--of
            life and death. A few minor caveats: First, a few of the chapters include a great deal
            of untranslated Latin, which may be an obstacle for some readers. (The Latin is
            translated in certain chapters, however.) Second, some of the essays would have
            benefitted from further copyediting; there are occasional typographic or grammatical and
            syntax errors that impede understanding. Finally, while the introduction does an
            excellent job of summarizing the subsequent chapters, I would have appreciated a more
            general discussion of the topics and questions addressed by the volume to accompany
            these summaries.</p>
        <p> </p>
        <p>None of these issues interferes with the overall utility of the collection, which, among
            other things, amply demonstrates the richness and complexity of medieval philosophical
            debate, especially in the thirteenth century. Several of the essays also bring attention
            to relatively under-studies works and authors, and the inclusion of the edition of the
            Tanner manuscript’s compendium adds to our understanding of how works were summarized,
            taught, and transmitted in this period.</p>
        <p> </p>
    </body>
</article>