<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.1 20151215//EN" "https://jats.nlm.nih.gov/archiving/1.1/JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article dtd-version="1.1" article-type="book-review" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">
    <front>
        <journal-meta>
            <journal-id>TMR</journal-id>
            <journal-title-group>
                <journal-title>The Medieval Review</journal-title>
            </journal-title-group>
            <issn pub-type="epub">1096-746X</issn>
            <publisher>
                <publisher-name>Indiana University</publisher-name>
            </publisher>
        </journal-meta>
        <article-meta>
            <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">24.01.06</article-id>
            <title-group>
                <article-title>24.01.06, Booker/Hummer/Polanichka (eds), Visions of Medieval History in North America and Europe</article-title>
            </title-group>
            <contrib-group>
                <contrib contrib-type="author">
                    <name>
                        <surname>Shane Bobrycki</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                    <aff>University of Vienna</aff>
                    <address>
                        <email>shane.bobrycki@univie.ac.at</email>
                    </address>
                </contrib>
            </contrib-group>
            <pub-date publication-format="epub" date-type="pub" iso-8601-date="2022">
                <year>2024</year>
            </pub-date>
            <product product-type="book">
                <person-group>
                    <name>
                        <surname>Booker, Courtney M., Hans Hummer, and Dana M. Polanichka, eds</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                </person-group>
                <source>Visions of Medieval History in North America and Europe: Studies on Cultural Identity and Power</source>
                <series>Cursor Mundi</series>
                <year iso-8601-date="2022">2022</year>
                <publisher-loc>Turnhout, Belgium</publisher-loc>
                <publisher-name>Brepols</publisher-name>
                <page-range>Pp. 451</page-range>
                <price>€120 (hardback)</price>
                <isbn>978-2-503-59628-0 (hardback)</isbn>
            </product>
            <permissions>
                <copyright-statement>Copyright 2024 Trustees of Indiana University. Indiana University provides the information contained in this file for non-commercial, personal, or research use only. All other use, including but not limited to commercial or scholarly reproductions, redistribution, publication or transmission, whether by electronic means or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited.</copyright-statement>
            </permissions>
        </article-meta>
    </front>
    <body>
        <p>Identity has long fascinated medievalists. How did medieval people understand themselves?
            How fixed or situational were their identities? How were identities used? The topic is
            not only tricky, but urgent. Appeals to “medieval” identities still justify hatred and
            violence. Few have tackled this topic more ably than Patrick Geary, whose searching,
            humane work on the subject and whose productive career are honored by this collection of
            fifteen essays exploring “identity in its various manifestations throughout medieval
            Europe” (9).</p>
        
        <p><italic>Visions </italic> does not self-identify as a Festschrift, but as a thematic
            collection (9) divided into sections on “Ethnic Identities” (Poly, Reimitz, Wolfram),
            “Inheritance and Identity” (Schoolman, Whitten, Hummer), “Religious Identities” (Beneš,
            Todorov, Polanichka), “Legal and Political Identities” (Koziol, Brown, Popa-Gorjanu),
            and “Memories, Texts, and Identities” (Maskarinec, Eldevik, Booker). But Geary’s
            inspiration is visible throughout (63-64, 76, 83, 124, 129-130, 147, 171-172, 257-258,
            335, 358-359, 373), and he graces the first and last footnotes like a scholarly Alpha
            and Omega (10n1, 411n101).</p>
        
        <p>The editors’ introduction (9-28) opens by defining identity as “how a person, group, or
            society sees, understands, and expresses itself” (9). Two pages (9-10) ably cover basics
            (only perhaps understating how much the outside gaze can shape identity). There is an
            illuminating meditation (10-15) on <italic>identitas</italic> and
                <italic>persona</italic> in the fourth-century rhetors Marius Victorinus and Chirius
            Fortunatianus, as curated by an eighth-century manuscript (Cologne, Dombibliothek, Cod.
            166), with admirable attention to how the medium informed the message. The manuscript’s
            “obsessive concern with being and the participation in existence that shapes
            consciousness, meaning, and identity” (15) was fascinating reading. The editors then
            segue to a contents-summary (16-24) defending the volume’s coherency while hinting at
            Geary’s influence.</p>
        
        <p>The first essay, in French, by Jean-Pierre Poly (31-62), examines 40 fourth-century
            military funerary inscriptions at Concordia (plus others). Two souls, Roman and
            non-Roman, abided in the breasts of these soldiers, to judge by their inscriptions. The
            observation is familiar, but Poly’s analysis, including attention to onomastics, status,
            deeds, and religion, is edifying. Those who lecture on this topic will find slide-worthy
            examples (e.g., 53, <italic>CIL</italic> 3.1.1 no. 3576: “I, a Frankish citizen, a Roman
            soldier in arms, / Always lifted my arm most virtuously in war”).</p>
       
        <p>Helmut Reimitz (63-82) examines ethnicity and ethnic identity (differentiated at 66) in
            what he playfully calls “our...colleagues” (67), Isidore of Seville, Gregory of Tours,
            and the Fredegar-Chronicle, with a focus on how Gregory and Fredegar, with similar
            material, diverged. While Gregory’s <italic>Histories</italic> gradually undermined the
            centrality of <italic>gentes</italic> (70-71), the Fredegar-Chronicle, by selective
            editing, genre, and juxtaposition, used Gregory to say the opposite: the Franks were the
            culmination of a history of peoples (72-74). The story may be familiar to those who know
            Reimitz’s excellent 2015 book, but this essay offers fresh nuance, and stresses that our
            medieval “colleagues” were aware of “alternative world views” (74). [1]</p>
        
        <p>Herwig Wolfram, doyen of the “Vienna School,” discusses the “Nemítzioi” (83-103), a Greek
            name derived from Slavic “mute ones” (84-85) used to describe Bavarians in an
            address-list of the <italic>De ceremoniis</italic> of Constantine VII Porphyrogenitos
            (913-959). The Bavarians and Eastern Franks--but <italic>not</italic> other
            Germans--were classed as <italic>Nemítzioi</italic>. Building on his earlier
            German-language work, Wolfram uses the contingent history of central European ethnonyms
            to make the wider point that medieval ethnic dividing-lines fall in places we might not
            expect.</p>
        
        <p>Edward M. Schoolman fruitfully examines (107-128) the framing of self as a component of
            inheritance in ninth- to eleventh-century Ravenna charters. He studies the “<italic>ex
                genere</italic>” formula (111-115, table 5.1), originally referring to ethnic origin
            (e.g., <italic>ex genere Francorum</italic>), but encompassing other birthrights (e.g.,
                <italic>ex genere consul</italic>, 112); family histories, especially involving
            women (115-122); and profession- or place-indicators (e.g., the personal names Ravennus
            and Ravenna, 123). Schoolman is especially illuminating on the anchoring role of women
            in a city that founded its identity on Galla Placidia more than Theoderic or
            Justinian.</p>
        
        <p>Sarah Whitten (129-150) continues the focus on gender by looking at legal identity among
            marginal persons, especially women, in early medieval southern Italy. She contends that
            the socially sidelined found in (Lombard) law a necessary protection and a means of
            self-assertion. Identity as legal subjects was bound up with agency as persons, but this
            applied more to women than men (139-40, 146). [2] Whitten shows that legal identity in
            southern Italy was meaningfully gendered. She also reveals how thoroughly Lombard law
            shaped case outcomes, with riveting examples from a rich but understudied dossier, the
            charters of Cava.</p>
        
        <p>Hans Hummer’s essay (151-167) on inheritance builds on his 2018 bookon kinship, which
            criticized social science for undervaluing spiritual kinship at the expense of blood
            relations. [3] Here the subject is property transmission. Inheritance, Hummer argues,
            was not a “zero-sum” game pitting “biogenetic” heirs against spiritual ones (163).
            Properties donated to ecclesiastical houses only sometimes descended from donors’
            blood-relatives (159-160). Even a skeptic, doubting that blood-heirs watching lands go
            to Fulda really saw the monks as “family,” must acknowledge the power of Hummer’s
            numerical and discursive arguments for the social centrality of spiritual kinship.</p>
        
        <p>Carrie Beneš offers a riveting study (171-190) of Jacopo da Varagine’s sacred geography.
            Better known as the author of the <italic>Golden Legend</italic>, this late
            thirteenth-century archbishop of Genoa was also his city’s chronicler and holy booster.
            Beneš examines three of Jacopo’s relic translation accounts (John the Baptist, Syrus,
            Philip and James), with an eye to how Jacopo used space and materiality to make the
            saints’ relics specially Genoese. The contrast with the <italic>Golden Legend</italic>
            is striking, vindicating Beneš’s contention (also expressed in her research on Jacopo’s
                <italic>Chronicle</italic>) that Jacopo was an author of many turns. With vivid
            examples (e.g., an epidemic-causing basilisk in a basilica), she illuminates questions
            of civic identity, materiality, space, and memory.</p>
        
        <p>Boris A. Todorov’s essay (191-213) treats the commemoration of the 1346 Turkish invasion
            of Bulgaria by Slavic hagiography and <italic>paterika</italic>. Todorov focuses on
            memory, trauma (esp. 194-195), and the relation of both to rulership. He argues that in
            the wake of Turkish military success, Slavonic hagiographical authors
            and--crucially--manuscript-compilers promoted Byzantine imperial values of philanthropy,
            charity, and piety. Historians have read “hagiography as political theology” before;
            what is striking here is how those dynamics operated in a literary context lacking the
            usual genres for <italic>Kaiserkritik</italic>: panegyrics, princely mirrors, histories
            (210).</p>
        
        <p>Dana M. Polanichka examines Dhuoda (215-253), a ninth-century aristocratic woman who
            authored a handbook on proper behavior for her (doomed) son William. Recently Dhuoda has
            enjoyed a research boom, to which Polanichka has already skillfully contributed. [4]
            Here she focuses on Dhuoda’s criticism of the ecclesiastical hierarchy, which Dhuoda’s
            lay and female identity forced her to couch delicately. Polanichka’s argument is partly
            from silence (220-223), partly from Dhuoda’s treatment of connected themes: rituals
            (223-229), clergymen (229-237), and, fascinatingly, dogs (237-241). Carolingianists will
            read with interest and pleasure.</p>
        
        <p>Geoffrey Koziol (257-286) addresses a venerable debate about how much or how little the
            eleventh-century Peace of God Movement built on Carolingian precedents. Koziol’s
            argument, building on his 2018 book, is that Carolingian mechanisms of peace-maintenance
            focused on centralized order, whereas post-Carolingian ones focused on decentralized
            self-help. [5] Despite similar-looking rhetoric, Koziol argues, these were dissimilar
            projects. With characteristic <italic>vim</italic> and close readings of primary
            sources, Koziol assembles a strong case against continuity.</p>
        
        <p>Warren Brown (287-306) compares eleventh- and fourteenth-century France, two periods of
            more-than-usual reported violence. As in his 2010 book, Brown stresses the embeddedness
            of violence in notions of order/disorder. [6] What violence counted as ordered? The two
            centuries answered this question differently, Brown argues. Fourteenth-century writers,
            because they saw kings as arbiters of violence, unanimously lamented out-of-control
            violence. Eleventh-century writers, because many of them saw nonroyal violence as
            legitimate, were less univocal (288). This shift-in-norms thesis is compelling, but in
            blood spilt and lives upended, the war-, famine-, and plague-struck fourteenth century
            also strike this reviewer as just more brutal than the 1000s.</p>
        
        <p>Cosmin Popa-Gorjanu discusses (307-332) anti-corruption legislation in thirteenth century
            Hungary. “Corruption” pits norms against norms, since a “bribe” in statutory law looks
            like old-fashioned “reciprocity” (310) to a working official. Popa-Gorjanu explores
            these dynamics (307-310, 328-330) in what is mostly a blow-by-blow account of
            anticorruption statutes in Hungarian decrees of 1222, 1231, 1267, 1298. There is a nice
            link with Todorov, Koziol, and Brown in the focus on royal accountability.</p>
        
        <p>Maya Maskarinec (335-356) tells a detective story about a composite inscription, partly
            eighth-century, partly twelfth-century, listing properties owned by the <italic>titulus
            </italic> of SS. Giovanni e Paolo in Rome alongside a confirmation of this
                <italic>titulus</italic>’ rights by a Pope Gregory. With deft pacing, she uncovers
            “a shrewd attempt to latch onto the past” (335). Maskarinec argues (350-352) that the
                <italic>titulus</italic> was responding to claims upon its vineyards from SS. Andrea
            e Gregorio across the street, using their rival’s great local authority, Gregory the
            Great, against them. Maskarinec solves a riddle, with Geary-esque insights about memory,
            but in her own bailiwick: a classic Festschrift-style essay, refreshing as a lemonade on
            a hot day.</p>
        
        <p>Another gem was John Eldevik’s study (357-377) on the <italic>Letter of Prester
                John</italic>. Scholars usually read this forged epistle, from the imaginary Prester
            John to the Byzantine emperor Manuel, as a reflection of Frederick Barbarossa’s imperial
            ambitions. Taking a cue from Bettina Wagner’s reassessment of the Überlieferung, Eldevik
            reads the <italic>Letter</italic> as the product of a more diffuse context: the
            (Bavarian) monasteries where manuscripts of the <italic>Letter </italic> were produced
            and consulted. While not denying the <italic>Letter</italic>’s Staufen links, Eldevik
            argues that it was consumed as a piece of monastic orientalism (361). Eldevik makes his
            case using codicological close- and far--reading, including the fact that the
                <italic>Letter </italic> was often added to already-finished manuscripts (364, with
            table 15.1). A stimulating, original contribution.</p>
        
        <p>Courtney M. Booker (379-420) looks at the early modern history of a supposed
                <italic>oratio</italic> by Boniface to Pippin, the first Carolingian king, in 751.
            Starting with the third edition (1586) of François Hotman’s
                <italic>Francogallia</italic>, where it first appeared in print, Booker follows this
            text through early modern texts and manuscripts (with excellent images: Figures 16.16).
            There is an overarching argument about the nexus of law, identity, and power (407-408),
            but the joy of this essay is Booker’s infectious enthusiasm for the hunt. One is put in
            mind of Ihor Ševčenko’s <italic>tour de force</italic> on the Toparcha Gothicus.</p>
        
        <p>The quality of the fare in this smorgasbord of learning is high. Even when contributors
            build on previously published work (admittedly often), it is always with fresh nuance.
            The book is well-edited, with good images and end-aids. Still, one must account for its
            self-proclaimed identity as a book about identity (9). Apart from the first two sections
            (where, for fresh insights, Schoolman and Whitten stood out), most of the essays are not
            fully “on topic.” There are gaps: much of the high and late Middle Ages, Spain, the
            British Isles, Scandinavia, Byzantium (mostly), Islam, minorities, and non-elites.
            Palaeogenetics, the cutting-edge of identity studies, is absent.</p>
       
        <p>These criticisms are irrelevant if, as one suspects, <italic>Visions</italic> is really a
            Festschrift to Geary. But despite many hints that this is the case (the book’s title,
            for instance, mirrors a well-known essay by Geary), the editors have taken pains not to
            say so outright. In the introduction, Geary’s words spring up like clover in a field (he
            is cited 24 times), but in the text (as opposed to the notes) he is not even named. The
            introduction ends with an elegiac reflection on the legacy of great scholars, but the
            editors use Georges Duby in Geary’s stead (23-24). No mention is made of a certain 2019
            conference in honor of Geary, with a similar title and cast of characters.</p>
        
        <p>Like a butterfly species evolving new colors, the Festschrift genre seems committed to
            self-concealment. Whether due to publisher disinterest, as posited by another TMR
            reviewer in a similar case, [7] or to a <italic>Festschriftverbot</italic> on the part
            of the mentor, or whatever else, <italic>Visions</italic> commits to its genre
            camouflage. In the end, the subterfuge does little harm. But for the record, these
            high-quality essays are most satisfying not as component parts of a project on identity,
            but as loving and variegated tributes to a wonderful teacher and colleague, one of the
            great medievalists of our time.</p>
        
        <p>--------</p>
        <p>Notes:</p>
        
        <p>1. Helmut Reimitz, <italic>History, Frankish Identity and the Framing of Western
                Ethnicity, 550-850</italic> (Cambridge, 2015). </p>
        
        <p>2. This complements her important essay on the occasional <italic>un</italic> importance
            of ethnic identity in conflicts among southern Italians: Sarah Whitten, “Franks, Greeks,
            and Saracens: Violence, Empire, and Religion in Early Medieval Southern Italy,”
                <italic>Early Medieval Europe</italic> 27 (2019): 251-278. </p>
        
        <p>3. Hans Hummer, <italic>Visions of Kinship in Medieval Europe</italic> (Oxford, 2018). </p>
        
        <p>4. E.g., Dana Polanichka, “<italic>Quasi per speculum</italic>: Vision, Vigilance and the
            Natural World in Dhuoda’s <italic>Liber manualis</italic>,” <italic>Journal of Medieval
                History</italic> 46 (2020): 1-22. </p>
        
        <p>5. Geoffrey Koziol, <italic>The Peace of God</italic> (Leeds, 2018), esp. 5-42. </p>
        
        <p>6. Warren Brown, <italic>Violence in Medieval Europe</italic> (New York, 2010), e.g. vii,
            8, 120. A closer engagement in this essay with Philippe Buc, “What is Order? In the
            Aftermath of the ‘Feudal Transformation’ Debates,” <italic>Francia </italic> 46 (2019):
            289-300, could have been illuminating.</p>
        
        <p>7. <ext-link
                xlink:href="https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/tmr/article/view/31726/35753"
                id="OWA579a092f-fff6-63b0-3516-509505a04642"
                >https://scholarworks.iu.edu/journals/index.php/tmr/article/view/31726/35753</ext-link></p>
    </body>
</article>
