<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.1 20151215//EN" "https://jats.nlm.nih.gov/archiving/1.1/JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article dtd-version="1.1" article-type="book-review">
    <front>
        <journal-meta>
            <journal-id>TMR</journal-id>
            <journal-title-group>
                <journal-title>The Medieval Review</journal-title>
            </journal-title-group>
            <issn pub-type="epub">1096-746X</issn>
            <publisher>
                <publisher-name>Indiana University</publisher-name>
            </publisher>
        </journal-meta>
        <article-meta>
            <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">21.09.18</article-id>
            <title-group>
                <article-title>21.09.18, Jakobsson/Mayburd, eds., Paranormal Encounters in Iceland 1150–1400</article-title>
            </title-group>
            <contrib-group>
                <contrib contrib-type="author">
                    <name>
                        <surname>Craig R. Davis</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                    <aff>Smith College</aff>
                    <address>
                        <email>cradavis@smith.edu</email>
                    </address>
                </contrib>
            </contrib-group>
            <pub-date publication-format="epub" date-type="pub" iso-8601-date="2021">
                <year>2021</year>
            </pub-date>
            <product product-type="book">
                <person-group>
                    <name>
                        <surname>Jakobsson, Ármann and Miriam Mayburd (eds.)</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                </person-group>
                <source>Paranormal Encounters in Iceland 1150–1400</source>
                <year iso-8601-date="2020">2020</year>
                <publisher-loc>Boston, MA</publisher-loc>
                <publisher-name>De Gruyter</publisher-name>
                <page-range>Pp. vii, 438</page-range>
                <price>$139.99 (hardback)</price>
                <isbn>978-158-0443-296 (hardback)</isbn>
            </product>
            <permissions>
                <copyright-statement>Copyright 2021 Trustees of Indiana University. Indiana University provides the information contained in this file for non-commercial, personal, or research use only. All other use, including but not limited to commercial or scholarly reproductions, redistribution, publication or transmission, whether by electronic means or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited.</copyright-statement>
            </permissions>
        </article-meta>
    </front>
    <body>
        <p>The 23 studies collected in this volume are the fruit of an international collaboration
            between 2012 and 2017 sponsored by the University of Iceland and Icelandic Research
            Fund. Their purpose is to explore and rethink "paranormal" encounters as described in
            medieval Icelandic literary texts. The term is "intentionally provocative" (2), chosen
            to stress (or at least respectfully acknowledge) the very human experience of
            encountering non-human or preternatural beings without prejudging the authenticity of
            these encounters or even insisting on their thematic or symbolic purpose in the
            particular narratives in which they appear. The volume is thus an excursus in historical
            anthropology, concerned with uncovering the cultural meaning of these experiences to the
            authors who recounted them so vividly and to the audiences who received these stories
            with so much obvious appreciation and regard.</p>
        <p>The collection is subdivided into three sections: (1) studies that that emphasize the
            experience of the paranormal encounter itself; (2) those offering a taxonomy of the
            different kinds of paranormal being thus encountered; and (3) a group that moves on to
            consider more critically the literary qualities or thematic purposes of these striking
            narratives.</p>
        <p>Part I: Experiencing the Paranormal</p>
        <p>In "'I See Dead People'": The Externalization of Paranormal Experience in Medieval
            Iceland," the lead author Ármann Jakobsson flags the focus of the project as a whole on
            popular cultural representations or folk beliefs with an allusion to the 1999 film
                <italic>The Sixth Sense</italic> about a child psychologist and his young patient
            who talks with the dead. Ármann explores similar intrusions from a traditional Icelandic
            "netherworld" into the life of characters in <italic>Brennu-Njáls saga</italic>, in
            particular, the premonitory <italic>gandreið</italic> (witch-ride) seen by the boy
            Hildiglúmr before the Burning and Flosi's unsettling dream of Irongrim, a figure who
            steps from a hillside to call out many of the chieftain's followers for bloody
            reprisals, intimating that violent deeds can never be forgotten, but will continue to
            haunt the minds of their perpetrators ever after. Even the saintly Njáll comforts his
            household with the promise that God will not let them burn both in this world and the
            next, so that the saga-writer externalizes his protagonist's faith in a parallel
            universe whose frontiers are interpenetrable with our own.</p>
        <p>Miriam Mayburd, in "It Was a Dark and Stormy Night: Haunted Saga Homesteads, Climate
            Fluctuations, and the Vulnerable Self," considers the impact of Iceland's stark natural
            environment and subsistence economy on the experience of ordinary people, not only in
            its subarctic landscape with a low population density, but also in the country's
            propensity for extreme weather events and other environmental stressors. Sagas dramatize
            the physical and psychological vulnerability of their human characters amidst these
            elemental extremes. They illustrate "the phenomenon of the dissolving self -- an
            estrangement from oneself that occurs when all the perceived boundaries between self and
            environment begin to collapse" (21). Mayburd observes that the saga characters most
            affected by hauntings are also those most challenged by their social environments,
            "anonymous common house folk and farming staff," that is, underprivileged people "whose
            marginality is accentuated by their social dependency" in the homes of their betters,
            removed from the support of their own birth families (30). "[S]aga characters who are
            strong-minded and fearless in the face of such crises tend to be the socially privileged
            and educated; these are the regional authority figures to whom the local people appeal
            for interventions over the hauntings" (30-31). Lack of social autonomy thus translates
            into loss of personal agency when encountering preternatural threats.</p>
        <p>Ásdís Egilsdóttir moves more explicitly into the realm of Christian tradition with "Happy
            Endings: The (Para)Normality of Miracles," which she finds to be paradoxical phenomena
            since miracles in medieval narratives, especially of healing, are both ubiquitous and
            anomalous simultaneously. They are presented as the natural and normal result of an
            intervention by a very unnatural and abnormal person, in fact one who more often than
            not is no longer even alive in the flesh, but whose physical remains provide access to
            his or her spiritual presence and good will for further intercession with God "who is
            the real miracle worker" (45). The saint's bodily remains, situated on the cusp of this
            world and the next, thus restore a healthful normative balance between the supplicant's
            own body and soul. </p>
        <p>Andrea Maraschi follows with "Þórgunna's Dinner and Other Medieval Liminal Meals: Food as
            Mediator between this World and the Hereafter," in which she "deconstructs" the
            nocturnal appearance in <italic>Eyrbyggja saga</italic> of an undead revenant, a tall
            naked Hebridean woman who cooks and serves a meal in the home of an inhospitable farmer
            as her body is being transported to another location for burial. Meal-sharing is a
            primeval form of human social relationship and meal-preparing is a further manifestation
            of traditional womanliness and noble hospitality. In this saga the departed Þórgunna is
            honored by her return to the kitchen to teach the stingy farmer a lesson, which he takes
            to heart.</p>
        <p>In "A Troll Did It?: Trauma as a Paranormal State in the
            <italic>Íslendingasögur</italic>," Marion Poilvez explores the similarities between
            personal traumas and paranormal encounters in that they can be experienced as
            inexplicable, "unexpected and disruptive, repetitive, difficult to express, and at the
            same time contagious," replicating themselves in recursions which perpetuate shared
            feelings of vulnerability. Poilvez suggests that hauntings embody suppressed memories of
            violation and abuse, the "past invading the present," or in Freudian terms, the
            relentless "return of the repressed" (80).</p>
        <p>Sarah Bienko Eriksen examines one of the most famous of Icelandic revenants in
            "Traversing the Uncanny Valley: Glámr in Narratological Space." She notes similarities
            between Grettir and the undead Glámr who curses the saga hero with a vision of the
            monster's hate-filled eyes staring back at him whenever Grettir finds himself alone in
            the dark. This curse implies to many readers that Glámr is, in some sense, Grettir's
            "double," a projection of the outlaw's own incorrigible hostility which makes his living
            in society impossible, but also his own company equally unbearable -- a moral and
            emotional dilemma that ultimately drags him to his death. Eriksen suggests that this
            doubling effect is created by the subtle use of an innovative technique in saga
            narrative, "internal focalization" (89), whereby the characteristically objective saga
            descriptions of words and deeds are manipulated by the author to reveal the interior
            perspectives of both monster and outlaw. Grettir thus transforms before the reader's
            eyes into a "monstrous outsider" himself with whose "monstrosity" we are now "forced" to
            "self-identify," creating a peculiarly intense and interesting character who is "greater
            than the sum of its parts" (99).</p>
        <p>In "On the Threshold: The Liminality of Doorways," Anna Katharina Heiniger considers the
            paranormal encounters that literally occur at the main entrance to an Icelandic
            farmstead, leading into or out of a transitional period in a saga's development, but one
            that brings about "the renegotiation and reorganization of the social order," as
            described in Arnold van Gennep's classic study, <italic>The Rites of Passage</italic>
            (1960).</p>
        <p>Sean B. Lawing studies "The Burial of Body Parts in Old Icelandic <italic>Grágás</italic>," a native law code containing an early statute requiring proper
            burial for any part of a baptized Christian discovered, as if of the whole person's
            corpse. Lawing demonstrates that Iceland was no backwater in this theological concern
            for the proper interment of believers in consecrated ground and that "even the humblest
            piece of human body ought to be properly laid to rest" in order to facilitate "its
            physical reassemblage and resurrection at the Last Judgement" (139).</p>
        <p>Daniel C. Remein writes on "Paranormal Prose: 'Para-Narrative' and Ice in the Icelandic
            Sagas." His metaphorical invocation of saga prose as ice may not be crystal-clear to all
            readers at first, but he proposes that the objective saga style, describing even
            paranormal events with a certain laconic factuality, replicates the nature of ice as
            seemingly bright and solid, but also brittle, shifting, unstable and sometimes even
            dangerous as the platform between up and down, here and there, the water below and air
            above, and a very uncertain avenue to the distant shore. Ice mimics the surface solidity
            of saga prose, so seemingly realistic and "hard," but making way for the presence of the
            paranormal that lies below, above or beyond it. </p>
        <p>Part II: Figures of the Paranormal</p>
        <p>Andrew McGillivray describes "Encounters with Hliðskjálf in Old Norse Mythology," the
            "Cliff-Perch" of Ásgarðr, high in the sky above Miðgarðr, from which the All-Father
            Ódinn looks out upon the world in all directions. It functions as an observation deck or
            listening post for various Norse gods, a surveillance apparatus or central intelligence
            headquarters situated to monitor "as many points as possible on the periphery" of the
            cosmos (185).</p>
        <p>Sandra Ballif Straubhaar offers "Ok flygr þat jafnan [And it's always flying]": Icelandic
            Figurations of Böðvarr bjarki's Monster" in <italic>Hrólfs saga kraka</italic>. This
            airborne predator is often adduced as an analogue of Grendel in the earlier Old English
            poem <italic>Beowulf</italic>, but Straubhaar concludes that this particular monster,
            far from being a traditionally pedestrian troll or giant, is more stylishly conceived as
            "a European Romanesque winged dragon" (198).</p>
        <p>Arngrímur Vídalín writes on "Demons, Muslims, Wrestling Champions: The Semantic History
                of <italic>Blámenn</italic> from the Twelfth to the Twentieth Century." <italic>Blámaður</italic> (Black Man) came to denote simply an African person by the
            nineteenth century in Iceland, but the term had sharply narrowed in semantic range from
            a whole panoply of paranormal beings from devils, trolls and giants, on the one hand, to
            berserks, sorcerers, heretics, 'Moors' and other kinds of human heathen, on the
            other.</p>
        <p>Kent Pettit writes on "The New Faith vs. The Undead: Christmas Showdowns," noting the
            frequent hauntings by animated corpses of refractory pagans during celebrations of
            Christ's nativity in both <italic>Grettis saga</italic> and <italic>Eyrbyggja
                saga</italic>. The removal or exorcism of these revenants, he argues, is intended to
            reinforce the triumph of Christianity in the land.</p>
        <p>Zuzana Stankovitsová contributes "Following up on Female <italic>fylgjur</italic>: A
            Re-Examination of the Concept of Female <italic>fylgjur</italic> in Old Icelandic
            Literature." The term <italic>fylgja</italic>, which literally means "follower," is
            frequently translated as "fetch" in English, denoting the ghost or wraith of a living
            person taken to be an omen of that individual's impending death. In Icelandic texts,
                <italic>fylgjur</italic> can appear in animal form, but the concept of a personified
            female <italic>fylgja</italic>, Stankovitsová argues, seems to be a fiction generated by
            scholars who associated the term with <italic>dísir</italic>, female protective spirits
            associated with individuals or families.</p>
        <p>Rebecca Merkelbach argues in "<italic>Dólgr í byggðinni</italic> [A Fiend in the
            Settlement]: Meeting the Social Monster in the Sagas of Icelanders," that monstrosity is
            conceived not primarily as a physical or ontological phenomenon, but as a moral and
            behavioral one. Humans like Grettir become monsters through their transgressive,
            antisocial behavior.</p>
        <p>Part III: Literature and the Paranormal</p>
        <p>Christopher Crocker observes that "Even a Henchman Can Dream: Dreaming at the Margins
                in <italic>Brennu-Njáls saga</italic>," noting that many dreams mentioned in that
            text are only minimally recounted or not at all, and often by low-ranking or "walk-on"
            characters like the overseer Kolr in the killing-match episode between rival housewives.
            The significance of unreported dreams by insignificant characters "may in fact be
            contingent upon the absence of their particular details": they are "words better left
            unsaid," but by their very suppression only serve to build a sense of foreboding from an
            independent, "but crucially corroborative perspective" (290).</p>
        <p>In "A Normal Relationship? Jarl Hákon and Þorgerðr Hölgabrúðr in Icelandic Literary
            Context," Þórdís Edda Jóhannesdóttir examines an episode in <italic>Jómsvíkinga
                saga</italic> in which the pagan Jarl Hákon sacrifices his son to recruit the aid of
            a female troll against the Jómsvikings. She notes that such a possibility would not have
            come as a surprise to medieval Christian Icelanders, since the old divinities were
            already understood to be devils in disguise, as argued by St. Augustine in his
                <italic>City of God</italic>, demonic powers who could naturally be invoked for
            nefarious purposes.</p>
        <p>Gunnvör S. Karlsdóttir offers "Priest Ketill's Journey to Rome," a humorous
                <italic>exemplum</italic> inserted into a later version of the <italic>Saga of
                Bishop Guðmundur Arason the Good</italic>, illustrating the increasing influence of
            the continental cult of the Blessed Mother in fourteenth-century Iceland.</p>
        <p>Ingibjörg Eyþórsdóttir considers "'Darraðarljóð' and Its Context within <italic>Njáls
                saga</italic>: Sorcery, Vision, <italic>Leizla</italic>?" She suggests that this
            episode in the saga is the adaptation of a West Nordic form, the<italic>leizla</italic>,
            literally a "guiding" or "leading," that is, the report of a visit to the Otherworld
            with premonitory import, here represented to have occurred just after the fateful Battle
            of Clontarf in 1016. The pagan Norns are seen to weave the fates of men on their bloody
            loom for the last time, apparently offering a glimpse of the religious change underway
            in the northern world.</p>
        <p>In "Paranormal Tendencies in the Sagas: A Discussion about Genre," Martina Ceolin argues
            that depictions of preternatural encounters may point to the kind of narrative world
            into which the reader is being led, but that this effect changed through time as the
            conventional features of different saga genres were mixed and matched and sometimes
            ironized in dynamic and heterogeneous ways. She concludes that "the analysis of genre
            within the saga corpus remains a complex and controversial matter, if not a paranormal
            experience in and of itself," unsettling the very notion of predictable narrative
            expectations (358).</p>
        <p>Shaun F. D. Hughes offers a novel interpretation of the undead in "Reading the Landscape
                in <italic>Grettis saga</italic>: Þórhallur, the <italic>meinvættur</italic> [harmful
            creature], and Glámur." By studying the physical topography of his haunted farm, Hughes
            concludes that Þórhallur had abused his relationship with the
                <italic>landvættir</italic> (guardians of the land) by overgrazing his extensive
            flocks. His shepherd Glámur kills one of these beings, but dies in the struggle,
            returning himself from the dead to enact their vengeance against his master.</p>
        <p>In "Trolling Guðmundr: Paranormal Defamation in <italic>Ljósvetninga saga</italic>," yoav
            tirosh (sic) shows how a prominent chieftain, even though manfully providing for and
            protecting his many children and dependents, could still be "queered" by imputations of
                <italic>argskapr</italic> (effeminacy, perversion) in tales told about him by his
            enemies -- here, the chieftain's nervous consultation with a witch to find out if
            vengeance would be taken on him for a killing. She says no, not exactly, but that his
            sons will suffer for his deed and, in fact, Guðmundr dies soon thereafter anyway,
            fulfilling his brother's prophetic dream of a dying ox. The uncanny nature of Guðmundr's
            demise in this version of the saga is designed to undermine his character in the eyes of
            the reader.</p>
        <p>Védís Ragnheiðardóttir writes on one of the <italic>riddarasögur</italic> (knights'
            sagas) in "'Meir af viel en karlmennsku' [More by trickery than manliness]: Monstrous
            Masculinity in <italic>Viktors saga ok Blávus</italic>." She notes that martial
            misdirection comes to be seen in this late chivalric romance not as quick-thinking
            cunning or noble fortitude, but as a kind of toxic masculinity or cowardly
            aggression.</p>
        <p>This collection offers a valuable compendium of paranormal episodes recounted in medieval
            Icelandic sagas, succinctly described and thoughtfully analyzed with depth and insight.
            The authors incidentally provide a fine update on the current state of saga scholarship
            in general.</p>
    </body>
</article>
