<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8" standalone="yes"?>
<!DOCTYPE article  PUBLIC "-//NLM//DTD JATS (Z39.96) Journal Archiving and Interchange DTD v1.1 20151215//EN" "https://jats.nlm.nih.gov/archiving/1.1/JATS-archivearticle1.dtd">
<article dtd-version="1.1" article-type="book-review">
    <front>
        <journal-meta>
            <journal-id>TMR</journal-id>
            <journal-title-group>
                <journal-title>The Medieval Review</journal-title>
            </journal-title-group>
            <issn pub-type="epub">1096-746X</issn>
            <publisher>
                <publisher-name>Indiana University</publisher-name>
            </publisher>
        </journal-meta>
        <article-meta>
            <article-id pub-id-type="publisher-id">21.06.04</article-id>
            <title-group>
                <article-title>21.06.04, Cooijmans, Monarchs and Hydrarchs</article-title>
            </title-group>
            <contrib-group>
                <contrib contrib-type="author">
                    <name>
                        <surname>Daniel Melleno</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                    <aff>University of Denver</aff>
                    <address>
                        <email>daniel.melleno@du.edu</email>
                    </address>
                </contrib>
            </contrib-group>
            <pub-date publication-format="epub" date-type="pub" iso-8601-date="2021">
                <year>2021</year>
            </pub-date>
            <product product-type="book">
                <person-group>
                    <name>
                        <surname>Cooijmans, Christian</surname>
                        <given-names/>
                    </name>
                </person-group>
                <source>Monarchs and Hydrarchs: The Conceptual Development of Viking Activity across the Frankish Realm (c. 750–940)</source>
                <year iso-8601-date="2020">2020</year>
                <publisher-loc>London, UK</publisher-loc>
                <publisher-name>Routledge</publisher-name>
                <page-range>Pp. 292</page-range>
                <price>$160.00 (hardback)</price>
                <isbn>978-0-36720-214-9 (hardback)</isbn>
            </product>
            <permissions>
                <copyright-statement>Copyright 2021 Trustees of Indiana University. Indiana University provides the information contained in this file for non-commercial, personal, or research use only. All other use, including but not limited to commercial or scholarly reproductions, redistribution, publication or transmission, whether by electronic means or otherwise, without prior written permission of the copyright holder is strictly prohibited.</copyright-statement>
            </permissions>
        </article-meta>
    </front>
    <body>
        <p>There has seldom been a better time to be a scholar of the Vikings. New discoveries and
            processes in archaeology have opened up rich fields of debate about the lives and
            activities of the inhabitants of what is typically referred to as the "Viking World."
            New theoretical approaches, such as diaspora theory, migration theory, and network
            theory are helping us to conceptualize this period in novel ways, moving away from older
            debates about violence and allowing us to instead investigate the myriad ways in which
            the Vikings (or more accurately, the Norse) engaged with the wider world. [1] And yet
            for all this attention and vibrant scholarship, there remains a surprising gap in the
            historiography of the Viking Age. Numerous books cover the Viking Age in the North
            Atlantic, in England and Ireland, and in Scandinavia. When it comes to the Continent,
            however, there has never been a single focused English monograph on the topic. Scholars
            have had to work through a wide body of articles and edited collections, doing most of
            the heavy lifting for themselves, in order to get a clear sense of the Viking impact on
            the Carolingian Empire. It is this gap that Christian Cooijmans' book, <italic>Monarchs
                and Hydrarchs,</italic> seeks to address by providing a coherent synthesis and
            analysis of Viking activity across Francia from the late 8th to the mid-10th
            century.</p>
        <p>In some ways, Cooijmans' book is a nod to that classic debate over Viking violence that
            has occupied the field since at least the 1960s. Indeed, it is with this debate that he
            begins the introduction to his work in a section titled "The story so far." But for
            Cooijmans the question is not whether Vikings engaged in violence (they did) or whether
            that violence was "normal" or "abnormal." Rather, the point of this work is to
            understand the methods and approaches of Viking violence, or, to put it more broadly, as
            Cooijmans does, "viking activity." [2] This may seem like a small distinction, but by
            shifting from violence or raiding to "activity" more broadly conceived he is able to
            encompass a much wider array of behavior, including not just raids on monasteries but
            also the logistics of long-term encampments in the late 9th century, and even the
            all-important system of commendation that frequently marked Franco-Scandinavian
            interaction. But rather than merely building a catalog or narrative of Viking activity
            in the Frankish world, what this work is undertaking, to put it in the author's own
            words, is the construction of a "conceptual development model" which will allow for the
            creation of "an abstract, phased paradigm of archetypal activity based on the compiled
            and collated data from the primary sources" (4). At its heart, what Cooijmans is seeking
            to do is to lay out the core patterns and structures that dictated where, when, and
            (most importantly) how and why Norse peoples engaged in Viking activity across Francia. </p>
        <p>So, how does Cooijmans go about constructing this model? After setting up some of the
            historiographical background in his first chapter, chapter 2 begins by focusing on "The
            Scandinavian perspective." This chapter lays out some of the key transformations, both
            political and economic, that set the stage for the Viking Age. The use of both textual
            and archaeological data effectively highlights the key importance of this sort of
            cross-disciplinary work in the field. Two key developments are highlighted here: the
            growth of political centralization on the one hand, and the burgeoning trade networks of
            the North Sea and Baltic on the other. In whole this chapter serves as a good
            introduction to the state of Scandinavia in this period and provides a sense of the
            drivers that led to Viking activity both in the Frankish world and more broadly.</p>
        <p>Of more importance for the work, and for the field more broadly, is the time spent in
            this chapter introducing the titular hydrarchs who will feature so prominently in this
            work going forward. The term itself originates from work on the Early Modern Atlantic by
            the historians Peter Linebaugh and Marcus Rediker and refers to, in Cooijmans' words,
            collections of Viking fleets which were, "unaffiliated, self-governing networks of
            political power – small-scale shipborne societies beyond the grasp of sovereign and
            commercial authorities" (32). While Cooijmans is not the first scholar of the Viking Age
            to make use of the concept this work is the first full-scale monograph to center the
            hydrarchy as fundamental to understanding the Viking Age. It is the flexibility of the
            hydrarchy system, centered on fleets able to move quickly, to grow or shrink as needed,
            to share and disseminate information broadly, and to adapt to changing circumstances
            over time that is key to unraveling the patterns of Viking activity on the Continent. </p>
        <p>Having established the Scandinavian context and set up his key structure for
            understanding the organization of Vikings abroad Cooijmans turns his attention to the
            Carolingian empire, where the remainder of the book will have its focus. Chapter 3
            provides a brief overview of the Carolingian world, effectively a parallel to the
            preceding chapter on Scandinavia, again focusing on political and economic structures. A
            quick overview of the political context (notably the division of the empire in 843) is
            provided and some of the key economic and administrative structures which would be
            impacted by the arrival of the Vikings are laid out. At its heart, this chapter can be
            understood to primarily be about setting up the playing field for those Scandinavians
            who we met in Chapter 2.</p>
        <p>Chapters 4 and 5 approach the main focus of the work as Cooijmans lays out
            Franco-Scandinavian interactions up to the mid-9th century. These chapters are quite
            short (12 and 20 pages respectively, including notes) and serve more to set the stage
            for later Viking activity than as a focus in their own right. Chapter 4 provides a brief
            discussion of early reports of raiding along coastal sites and some discussion of how
            trade and key diplomatic interactions might have served as vectors for information
            transfer necessary for early Viking hydrarchies to get their start on the Continent.
            Chapter 5 give us a clear sense of the uptick in intensity witnessed during the last
            years of Charlemagne's reign and the first decades of Louis the Pious' with some nice
            discussion of the evolution of practices. In unpacking the potential significance of
            this early activity Cooijmans demonstrates his ability to take often sparse or stubborn
            primary sources and wrest potential patterns and logic from them. </p>
        <p>In chapter 6 of the book, "Intensified Viking Activity" Cooijmans really hits his stride.
            The chapter stands at almost one hundred pages, nearly a third of the length of the
            book, and it is here that we can really see Cooijmans' focus and his goal of
            accumulating as much data as possible in order to successfully construct a model that
            can be applied to Viking activity not just on a case by case or location by location
            basis, but across the entirety of the Frankish world. Detailed sections on the raids
            themselves, on the practice of encampment, and on the various means by which the
            Carolingians sought to prevent or blunt Norse predation encompass a wide array of
            sources and nicely cover the range of Viking activities during the height of the Viking
            Age. Central to all of this activity is the idea of hydrarchy, that flexible system
            which allowed numerous Viking bands to operate across key regions of the Frankish realm,
            to engage not just in raiding but in tribute collection, in mercenary work, in trade,
            and even in the very political system of the Franks themselves. Working through this
            chapter can be somewhat daunting given its size and depth and the existence of numerous
            subsections (and even sub-subsections) can sometimes make it hard to establish a clear
            narrative of the period, but the result is a comprehensive overview of the Vikings not
            just as violent invaders but as rational actors with an increasing familiarity with the
            Frankish world and the willingness to adapt as circumstances warranted.</p>
        <p>Having accumulated and run through his data Cooijmans' final major chapter shifts back
            from the material itself to the larger conceptual model at the heart of his
            investigation. In this chapter he puts forth the second thrust of his argument (beyond
            the importance of hydrarchy), dividing Franco-Scandinavian interaction into a series of
            four phases and arguing for an "archetypal sequence of Scandinavian encroachment across
            the Frankish realm" (209). In Phase One, politico-economic pressure at home and from
            abroad creates connections between Scandinavia and the Continent and spurs the initial
            formation of hydrarchies. In Phase Two, Viking activity impinges on the periphery of the
            Frankish world and we see some limited political links forming between Franks and
            Norsemen. Spurred on by early successes, Phase Three sees a major expansion of Viking
            activity beyond coasts, further inland and marks the rise of encampments and even
            full-scale Scandinavian entry into the Frankish world via the granting of various
            benefices. Finally, in Phase Four the hydrarchies peter out, the victims of their own
            success and of a changing landscape both at home and abroad in the Frankish world.
            Having established this sequence, the rest of the chapter works to demonstrate the
            validity of this sequence in the three key theaters of Viking activity, the Lower Rhine,
            Seine, and Loire basins. The choice to split these regions apart and to demand that each
            phase be visible in each area feels a bit artificial given his earlier point about the
            flexibility and connectivity of hydrarchies of Viking networks across wide areas, but
            all in all the model works well and makes sense as a way of conceptualizing how Viking
            activity unfolded across the period. Cooijmans closes the chapter with the guarded but
            optimistic statement that "the conceptual development model may be provisionally
            approved, making it the first functional schema of its kind to deal with the reach and
            repercussions of viking activity. Whilst acknowledging that individual Scandinavian
            hosts acted with forethought and intent, this innovative model demonstrates hydrarchy as
            a whole to have adhered to an overarching paradigm of regional movement and
            encroachment" (228). </p>
        <p>All in all, the work that Cooijmans has done in this book is meticulous and well thought
            out. Having constructed and validated his model to his satisfaction, the book then
            closes with some very brief remarks (4 pages in total) about the value of the model and
            its potential utility for investigating other areas of the Frankish world such as the
            Garonne Valley, and pushes for the use of the hydrarchy as a tool for thinking about
            Norse activity across the Viking World more broadly. Of the two, I can't help but feel
            that the hydrarchy approach will be the more popular and useful contribution to the
            field as a whole given its applicability not just to the Frankish concept but more
            broadly across the Viking World. But for scholars of Francia the conceptual model has
            the potential to expand both the analysis of extant data in new ways and to help fill in
            of gaps in the historical record that plague the study of Viking activity on the
            Continent. Cooijmans is not shy about the importance of deductive reasoning when working
            with our often spotty or heavily biased medieval sources, and in this practice the model
            will be of tremendous use.</p>
        <p>There is perhaps only one major critique worth highlighting at the close of this review.
            In my introduction I noted that Cooijmans is working to fill a key gap in the
            historiography of the Viking Age by bringing Francia to the forefront. This is true, but
            it is worth couching this to a certain extent because what Cooijmans cares about, first
            and foremost, is still <italic>Viking</italic> activity. To be fair, he is never shy
            about this focus, but in his push to create a conceptual model for this Viking activity
            in particular it does feel at times that certain key engagements between Franks and
            Norsemen are left by the way side. For any substantive discussion of the diplomatic
            conferences of the late 8th and early 9th century, for instance, one must turn to Pierre
            Bauduin's <italic>Le Monde franc et les Vikings</italic>. [3] It would have been nice to
            see a bit more discussion of the titular monarchs of Scandinavia as well as the
            hydrarchs and to see how the interplay of elements such as Anskar's missions, the
            on-going relationship between the Carolingians and the kings of Denmark, or the shifting
            internal politics of the later Frankish kings fit into and impacted the model that he is
            constructing. What we get is a very clear and detailed picture of Viking activity in
            Francia but not always as clear a picture of the larger context or significance of that
            activity more broadly. </p>
        <p>Regardless, <italic>Monarchs and Hydrarchs</italic> will undoubtably push the study and
            discussion of Franco-Scandinavian interaction forward. Beyond the thorough analysis
            itself, the book is replete with useful charts, tables, and maps which will delight both
            graduate students and established scholars alike. No more will each individual have to
            scour the numerous annals to compile a list of attacks, encampments, and tribute
            payments, for instance. In this, Cooijmans has given a gift to the field. Above all, no
            work of this detail and breadth exists and it was sorely needed. With his thoughtful
            analysis of the available data, and his ability to read between the lines and
            extrapolate out patterns, Cooijmans exposes the complexity of Viking activity on the
            Continent. He champions new ways of conceptualizing Viking activity and organization,
            centered on the agency, rationality, and flexibility of the Norse. The work is without a
            doubt a must read whether one is specifically interested in Franco-Scandinavian
            engagement or in the Viking Age as a whole.</p>
        <p>Notes:</p>
        <p>1. Lesley Abrams, "Diaspora and Identity in the Viking Age," <italic>Early Medieval
                Europe</italic> 20, no. 1 (February 1, 2012): 17-38; Judith Jesch, <italic>The
                Viking Diaspora</italic> (London: Routledge, 2015); Shane McLeod, <italic>The
                Beginning of Scandinavian Settlement in England: The Viking "Great Army" and Early
                Settlers, c. 865-900</italic> (Turnhout: Brepols, 2014); Søren Sindbaek, "Crafting
            Networks in Viking Towns," <italic>Medieval and Modern Matters</italic> 4 (2013):
            119-132.</p>
        <p>2. Cooijmans choice in his work to leave "viking" uncapitalized points to a subtle but
            largely unaddressed debate in the field over how (and whether) to disentangle raiding
            from identity. This review article will default to the standard practice of capitalizing
            except when quoting Cooijmans directly.</p>
        <p>3. Pierre Bauduin, <italic>Le monde franc et les Vikings: VIIIe-Xe siècle</italic>
            (Paris: Albin Michel, 2009).</p>
    </body>
</article>