Issues in Replication and Stability of Least-cost Path Calculations
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
An important and frequently used tool in archaeological spatial analysis is least-cost path (LCP) analysis to compute routes connecting a set of targets. The outcome depends on the cost model chosen and the topographic data used. A slope-dependent cost model requires a digital elevation model (DEM) that should reflect the landscape in the past. It is often impossible to reconstruct the past terrain, and modern high-resolution elevation data results in problematic storage requirements and computation times. This article presents a case study that explores issues in replication and stability of LCP calculations for pairs of targets that are close to known old trade routes. A large number of cost models is tested based on two topographic data sets, including DEMs of two different resolutions (25 m and 50 m). The cost models use six different slope-dependent cost functions suggested by various authors for pedestrian movement. Moreover, a slope-dependent cost function is applied that results in LCPs including hairpin curves if the slope exceeds a predefined critical value. It is shown that the best-performing LCP sets for the two topographic data sets are closely related but not identical. Moreover, reasons for the failure of LCP reconstructions for some old route sections are discussed.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
From 18 May 2018, the contents of Studies in Digital Heritage are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0). Our submitting authors pay no fee and retain the copyright to their own work.
How this works: to submit their work to the journal, authors grant Studies in Digital Heritage a nonexclusive license to distribute the work according to a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. Once an article is published, anyone is free to share and adapt its contents—provided only that they do so for noncommercial purposes and properly attribute the shared or adapted information. Details of these terms can be found on the Creative Commons website.
Download SDH’s full author agreement here
Studies in Digital Heritage will insert the following note at the end of any work published in the journal:
© [Year] by the authors. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution License CC BY-NC 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
References
Norbert Andernach. 1984. Entwicklung der Grafschaft Berg. In Guido de Wird, ed. Land im Mittelpunkt der Mächte: Die Herzogtümer Jülich, Kleve, Berg. Kleve: Boss-Verlag, 63–73.
Tyler Bell and Gary Lock. 2000. Topographic and cultural influences on walking the Ridgeway in later prehistoric times. In Gary Lock, ed. Beyond the Map: Archaeology and Spatial Technologies. Amsterdam: IOS Press, 85–100.
James Conolly and Mark Lake. 2006. Geographical Information Systems in Archaeology, Cambridge Manuals in Archaeology, Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Burkhard Dietz ed. 1988. Erich Philipp Ploennies, Topographia Ducatus Montani (1715), Bergische Forschungen XX, Neustadt/Aisch: Schmidt.
Jonathon E. Ericson and R. Goldstein. 1980. Work Space: A New Approach to the Analysis of Energy Expenditure within Site Catchments. Anthropology UCLA 10, 1&2, 21–30.
Michael F. Goodchild and Gary J. Hunter. 2001. A simple positional accuracy measure for linear features. Int. J. Geographical Information Science 11, 3 (1997, received 01 Sep 2001, published online 06 Aug 2010), 299–306. https://doi.org/10.1080/136588197242419
Irmela Herzog. 2013a. Theory and Practice of Cost Functions. In Francisco Contreras, Mercedes Farjas & Francisco Javier Melero, eds. Fusion of Cultures: Proc. 38th Annual Conference on CAA, Granada, Spain, April 2010. Oxford: Archaeopress, 375–382.
Irmela Herzog. 2013b. The Potential and Limits of Optimal Path Analysis. In Andrew Bevan & Mark Lake, eds. Computational Approaches to Archaeological Spaces. Walnut Creek: Left Coast Press, 179–211.
Irmela Herzog. 2013c. Least-cost networks. In Graeme Earl, Timothy Sly, Angeliki Chrysanthi, Patricia Murrieta Flores, Constantinos Papadopoulos, Iza Romanowska & David Wheatley, eds. Archaeology in the Digital Era. Papers from the 40th Annual Conference of Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA), Southampton, 26-29 March 2012, Vol. I. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press, 237–248.
Irmela Herzog. 2017. Reconstructing Pre-Industrial Long Distance Roads in a Hilly Region in Germany, Based on Historical and Archaeological Data. Studies in Digital Heritage 1(2), 642–660. https://doi.org/10.14434/sdh.v1i2.23283
Irmela Herzog. 2020. Spatial analysis based on cost functions. In Mark Gillings, Piraye Hacigüzeller, & Gary Lock, eds. Archaeological Spatial Analysis: A Methodological Guide to GIS . London and New York: Routledge, Taylor & Francis Group, 333–358.
Irmela Herzog and Axel Posluschny. 2011. Tilt – Slope-Dependent Least Cost Path Calculations Revisited. In Erzsebet Jerem, Ferenc Redő & Vajk Szeverényi, eds. On the Road to Reconstructing the Past. Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA). Proceedings of the 36th International Conference. Budapest, April 2-6, 2008. Archeaeolingua: Budapest, 212– 218.
Ian J. Irmischer and Keith C. Clarke. 2017. Measuring and modeling the speed of human navigation. Cartography and Geographic Information Science 45(2), 177–186. https://doi.org/10.1080/15230406.2017.1292150
Günter Jacobi. 2010. 356 Rechnungsbelege des 15. Jahrhunderts aus der Kellnerei des Amtes Steinbach. Schriftenreihe des Bergischen Geschichtsvereins Rhein-Berg e.V. 62. Bergisch Gladbach.
Wilhelm Janssen. 2014. Das Bergische Land im Mittelalter. In Stefan Gorißen, Horst Sassin & Kurt Wesoly, eds., Geschichte des Bergischen Landes 1: Bis zum Ende des alten Herzogtums 1806. Bielefeld: Verlag für Regionalgeschichte, 24–139.
Eric Langmuir. 2004. Mountaincraft and Leadership, Revised Third Edition. Cordee, UK: Mountain Leader Training England & Mountain Leader Training Scotland.
Joseph Lewis. 2021. Probabilistic Modelling for Incorporating Uncertainty in Least Cost Path Results: a Postdictive Roman Road Case Study. J. Arch. Method and Theory 28, 911–924. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10816-021-09522-w
Marco Llobera and T. J. Sluckin. 2007. Zigzagging: Theoretical insights on climbing strategies, J. Theoretical Biology 249, 206–217.
Arnold Mercator 1575. Grundtliche Beschreibungh vnd Gelegenheit etlicher warer Grenntzen dem Bergischen Ampt Windeck vnd Herschafft Hombergh betreffend. Map copied by Hans Weirich in Issues in Replication and Stability of Least-cost Path Calculations 5:21
Published in 1999, along with 2 pages describing the history of the map by Hans Weirich, Lothar Wirths, and Klaus Pampus: Grenzen des Bergischen Amtes Windeck und der Herrschaft Homburg. Bergischer Geschichtsverein, Abt. Oberberg e.V.
Alberto E. Minetti, Christian Moia, Giulio S. Roi, Davide Susta & Guido Ferreti. 2002. Energy cost of walking and running at extreme uphill and downhill slopes. J. Applied Physiology 93, 1039–1046.
Herbert Nicke. 2000. Die Brüderstraße: Aus der Geschichte der alten Landstraße von Köln nach Siegen, Wiehl: Martina Galunder-Verlag.
Herbert Nicke. 2001a. Vergessene Wege: Das historische Fernwegenetz zwischen Rhein, Weser, Hellweg und Westerwald, seine Schutzanlagen und Knotenpunkte, Nümbrecht: Martina Galunder-Verlag.
Herbert Nicke. 2001b. Die Heidenstraße: Geschichte und Landschaft entlang der historischen Landstraße von Köln nach Kassel, Wiehl: Martina Galunder-Verlag.
Friedrich.Wilhelm Oediger. 1967. Die Erzdiözese Köln um 1300. Erstes Heft: Der Liber Valoris. Publikationen der Gesellschaft für rheinische Geschichtskunde, XII, 9(1), Bonn: Peter Hanstein- Verlag.
Klaus Pampus 1998. Urkundliche Erstnennungen oberbergischer Orte. Beiträge zur Oberbergischen Geschichte. Sonderband 1, Gummersbach: Oberbergische Abt. 1924 e.V. des Bergischen Geschichtsvereins.
Rebecca M. Seifried and Chelsea A. M. Gardner. 2019. Reconstructing historical journeys with least- cost analysis: Colonel William Leake in the Mani Peninsula, Greece. J. Arch. Sc. Reports 24, 391– 411.
Michael John De Smith, Michael F. Goodchild, and Paul Longley. 2007. Geospatial Analysis. A Comprehensive Guide to Principles, Techniques and Software Tools, Leicester: Troubadour Publishing.
Waldo Tobler. 1993. Non-isotropic geographic modeling. Technical Report No. 93-1. Retrieved October 30, 2021 from https://cloudfront.escholarship.org/dist/prd/content/qt05r820mz/qt05r820mz.pdf
Philip Verhagen. 2013. On the Road to Nowhere? Least Cost Paths, Accessibility and the Predictive Modelling Perspective. In Francisco Contreras, Mercedes Farjas & Francisco Javier Melero, eds. Fusion of Cultures: Proc. 38th Annual Conference on CAA, Granada, Spain, April 2010. Oxford: Archaeopress, 383–390.
Philip Verhagen and Karen Jeneson. 2012. A Roman Puzzle: Trying to Find the Via Belgica with GIS. In Angeliki Chrysanthi, Patricia Murrieta Flores & Constantinos Papadopoulus, eds. Thinking Beyond the Tool: Archaeological Computing and the Interpretive Process. Oxford: Archaeopress, 123–130.