Structure from Motion and Archaeological Excavation: Experiences of the Via Consolare Project in Pompeii
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
The last decade of advances in Image-Based Modeling (IBM) data acquisition based on Structure from Motion (SfM) have made it possible as never before to record excavated archaeological deposits, historical architectural remains, artifacts, and geographical surroundings in the field. Armed only with digital cameras and low-cost or open-source software, researchers can now produce accurate point clouds of millions of points, capturing archaeological information in high-resolution detail. But what changes will IBM really bring to the standards, requirements, and expectations of practical field methodology for projects operating on shoe-string budgets? Since 2010, the Via Consolare Project, a small archaeological research project from a State level University, has employed an entirely open-source and “free for academic use” IBM pipeline to record a variety of archaeological features in Insula VII 6 and the “Villa delle Colonne a mosaico” in Pompeii. Ranging from surviving architecture, to rubble fill layers, to the interiors of inaccessible cisterns and drains, this work has been carried out in preparation for the eventual coordination of these data into a 3D GIS of all recorded stratigraphy. Rarely were sufficient resources available for dedicated equipment or personnel to be devoted to this task. While practical implementation, even in a low-budget excavation environment, has confirmed that this technology can indeed augment archaeological field documentation and provide investigation opportunities that would otherwise be impossible, it failed to replace traditional handdrafted recording techniques and was found to present significant challenges and a number of hidden costs. This emphasizes a need for appropriate and cautious planning in implementation, especially in projects with limited means.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License.
From 18 May 2018, the contents of Studies in Digital Heritage are licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International License (CC BY-NC 4.0). Our submitting authors pay no fee and retain the copyright to their own work.
How this works: to submit their work to the journal, authors grant Studies in Digital Heritage a nonexclusive license to distribute the work according to a CC BY-NC 4.0 license. Once an article is published, anyone is free to share and adapt its contents—provided only that they do so for noncommercial purposes and properly attribute the shared or adapted information. Details of these terms can be found on the Creative Commons website.
Download SDH’s full author agreement here
Studies in Digital Heritage will insert the following note at the end of any work published in the journal:
© [Year] by the authors. This article is an open-access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution License CC BY-NC 4.0 (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
References
Michael Anderson and Damian Robinson, with contributions by Hilary E. M. Cool, Richard Hobbs, Charlene Murphy, Jane Richardson, Robyn Veal, Helen White, Will Wootton. 2018. House of the Surgeon, Pompeii: Excavations in the Casa del Chirurgo (VI 1, 9-10.23). Oxford: Oxbow.
Michael Anderson. 2015. Public buildings and private opportunities: some dynamics in Pompeii's urban development. Journal of Roman Archaeology 28 (2015), 71-96.
Michael Anderson. 2010. Precision Recording of Pompeian Standing Remains via Stitched Rectified Photography. In Bernard Frischer, Jane W. Crawford, et al., eds. Making History Interactive. Proceedings of the 37th International Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA). Williamsburg, Virginia, March 22-26, 2009. Oxford: Archaeopress.
Masanori Aoyagi and Umberto Pappalardo, eds. 2015. Pompei. Regiones VI-VII. Insula Occidentalis. Collana Pompei, vol. 1. Naples: Valtrend.
Paul Arthur. 1986. Problems of the urbanisation of Pompeii: excavations 1980-1981. Antiquaries Journal 66 (1986), 29-44.
Juan A. Barceló, Oscar De Castro, David Travet, and Oriol Vicente. 2003. “A 3D Model of an Archaeological Excavation.” In M. Doerr and S. Apostolis eds. The Digital Heritage of Archaeology. Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology. Athens, 85–87.
Juan A. Barceló and Oriol Vicente. 2004. “Some problems in archaeological excavation 3D modelling.” In Ausserer, K. F., Borner, W., Goriany, M., Karlhuber-Vockl, L. (eds.), Enter the Past: The E-way into the Four Dimensions of Cultural Heritage. CAA 2003, BAR International Series 1227. Archaeopress, 400-404.
Simone Bianco, Gianluigi Ciocca, and Davide Marelli. 2018. “Evaluating the Performance of Structure from Motion Pipelines.” Journal of Imaging 4, 98; doi:10.3390/jimaging4080098.
Francesco Carocci, Emilio De Albentiis, Mauro Gargiulo, and Fabrizio Pesando. 1990. Le Insulae 3 e 4 della Regio VI di Pompei: Un'Analisi Storico – Urbanistica. Rome: G. Bretschneider.
Paolo Cignoni, Marco Callieri, Massimiliano Corsini, Matteo Dellepiane, Fabio Ganovelli, and Guido Ranzuglia. 2008. “MeshLab: an Open-Source Mesh Processing Tool.” Sixth Eurographics Italian Chapter Conference. The Eurographics Association, 129-136. http://dx.doi.org/10.2312/LocalChapterEvents/ItalChap/ItalianChapConf2008/129-136
Paolo Cignoni, Claudio Montani, Claudio Rocchini, Roberto Scopigno, and Marco Tarini. 1999. “Preserving attribute values on simplified meshes by resampling detail textures.” The Visual Computer 15, 10 (1999), 519–539.
CloudCompare (version 2.X) [GPL software]. Retrieved from http://www.cloudcompare.org/
Filippo Coarelli and Fabrizio Pesando, eds. 2006. Rileggere Pompei. 1. L'Insula 10 della Regio VI. Rome: L'Erma di Bretscheider.
Sara Cucchiaro, Daniel J. Fallu, Pengzhi Zhao, Clive Waddington, David Cockcroft, Paolo Tarolli, Antony G. Brown. 2020. Chapter 6 - SfM photogrammetry for GeoArchaeology. In Developments in Earth Surface Processes, Volume 23 Remote Sensing of Geomorphology, 183-205.
Jeroen De Reu, Gertjan Plets, Geert Verhoeven, Philippe De Smedt, Machteld Bats, Bart Cherretté, Wouter De Maeyer, Jasper Deconynck, Davy Herremans, Pieter Laloo, Marc Van Meirvenne, Wim De Clercq. 2013. “Towards a three-dimensional cost-effective registration of the archaeological heritage.” Journal of Archaeological Science 40, 1108-1121. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2012.08.040
Jeroen De Reu, Philippe De Smedt, Davy Herremans, Marc Van Meirvenne, Pieter Laloo, and Wim De Clercq. 2014. “On Introducing an Image-based 3D Reconstruction Method in Archaeological Excavation Practice.” Journal of Archaeological Science 41, 251–262.
Hélène Dessales, Jean Ponce, Mathilde Carrive, Julien Cavero, Julien Dubouloz, Éloïse Letellier Frédérique Marchand-Beaulieu, Florence Monier, Ambre Péron, Agnès Tricoche, Yves Ubelmann. 2015. “Pompéi. Villa de Diomède. Chronique des activités archéologiques de l'École française de Rome.” Ecole Française de Rome (Rome), Les cités vésuviennes https://doi.org/10.4000/cefr.1293
Hélène Dessales, Jean Ponce, Clotilde Boust, Chapelin Guilhem, Mathilde Carrive, Julien Cavero, Arnaud Coutelas, Rita Deiana, Marco Di Ludovico, Giuseppina De Martino, Julien Dubouloz, Éloïse Letellier-Taillefer, Anne Maigret, Gaetano Manfredi, Frédérique Marchand-Beaulieu, Andrea Milanese, Claudio Modena, Florence Monier, Ambre d’Harcourt-Péron, Alban-Brice Pimpaud, Andrea Prota, Enzo Rizzo, Amedeo Rossi, Alfonso Santoriello, Agnès Tricoche and Maria Rosa Valluzzi. 2016. “Pompéi. Villa de Diomède. Chronique des activités archéologiques de l'École française de Rome.” Ecole Française de Rome (Rome), Les cités vésuviennes. https://doi.org/10.4000/cefr.1543
Michael Doneus, G. Verhoeven, M. Fera, C. Briese, M. Kucera, and W. Neubauer. 2011. “From Deposit to Point Cloud—A Study of Low-Cost Computer Vision Approaches for the Straightforward Documentation of Archaeological Excavations.” In Geoinformatics. XXIIIrd Int. CIPA Symp, Vol. 6, edited by A Čepek. Prague: Czech University Press, 81–88.
Matthew Douglass, Sam Lin, and Michael Chodoronek. 2015. “The Application of 3D Photogrammetry for In-Field Documentation of Archaeological Features.” Advances in Archaeological Practice 3(2), 136–152.
Benjamin Ducke, David Score, and Joseph Reeves (Oxford Archaeology). 2011. “Multiview 3D Reconstruction of the Archaeological Site at Weymouth from Image Series.” Computers & Graphics (2011), 357-382.
Eos Systems Inc, 2012. PhotoModeler Scanner. http://www.photomodeler.com/
Laurentino García y García. 2006. Danni di guerra a Pompei. Una dolorosa vicenda quasi dimenticata. Rome: L'Erma di Bretschneider.
Susie Green, Andrew Bevan, and Michael Shapland. 2014. “A Comparative Assessment of Structure from Motion Methods for Archaeological Research.” Journal of Archaeological Science 46, 173–181.
Mario Grimaldi, ed. Pompei. La Casa di Marco Fabio Rufo. Collana Pompei, vol. 2. Naples: Valtrend.
Christine Jones, Elizabeth Church. 2020. “Photogrammetry is for everyone: Structure-from-motion software user experiences in archaeology.” Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports 30 (2020):102261.
Rick F. J. Jones and Damian Robinson. 2007. “Intensification, heterogeneity and power in the development of insula VI I.” In John J. Dobbins and Pedar W. Foss, eds. The World of Pompeii. London: Routledge, 389-406.
Markos Katsianis, Spyros Tsipidis, Kostas Kotsakis, and Alexandra Kousoulakou. 2008. “A 3D Digital Workflow for Archaeological Intra-Site Research Using GIS.” Journal of Archaeological Science 35 (3), 655–667. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jas.2007.06.002
Michael Kazhdan, Hugues Hoppe. 2013. “Screened poisson surface reconstruction.” ACM Transactions on Graphics. 32, 3 (2013), Article 29. https://doi.org/10.1145/2487228.2487237
Victor Klinkenberg. 2016. “Are we there yet? 3D GIS in archaeological research, the case of Tell Sabi Abyad, Syria.” In Hans Kammermans, Wieke de Neef, Chiara Piccoli, Axel G. Posluschny and Roberto Scopigno (eds.) The Three Dimensions of Archaeology: Proceedings of the XVII UISPP World Congress (1-7 September 2014, Burgos, Spain) Vol. 7: Sessions A4b and A12. Archaeopress, 39-47.
Anne Laidlaw and Marco S. Stella. 2014. The House of Sallust in Pompeii (VI 2, 4). Journal of Roman Archaeology Supplementary Series 98. Portsmouth, Rhode Island.
Giacomo, Landeschi. 2019. “Rethinking GIS, three-dimensionality and space perception in archaeology.” World Archaeology. Vol. 51, no. 1, 17-32.
Martijn Van Leusen and Gay Nobles. 2018. “3D Spatial Analysis: the Road Ahead.” In Mieko Matsumoto and Espen Uleberg (eds.) Oceans of Data: Proceedings of the 44th Annual Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology. Archaeopress, 471-478.
L. M. Losier, J. Pouliot, and M. Fortin. 2007. “3D Geometrical Modeling of Excavation Units at the Archaeological Site of Tell ‘Acharneh (Syria).” Journal of Archaeological Science 34 (2), 272–288. doi:10.1016/j.jas.2006.05.008.
David G. Lowe. 2004. “Distinctive Image Features from Scale-Invariant Keypoints.” International Journal of Computer Vision 60, 2 (2004), 91–110.Yasutaka Furukawa and Jean Ponce. 2010. “Accurate, Dense, and Robust Multi-View Stereopsis.” IEEE Trans. on Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence 32, 8 (2010), 1362-1376.
José María Luzón and Ma del Carmen Alonso. 2017. Excavaciones arqueológicas en la casa de la Diana Arcaizante en Pompeya. http://www.dianaarcaizante.com/es/capitulo-7/55-Escanometria/6
Stefania Merlo 2004. “The ‘Contemporary Mind’. 3D GIS as a Challenge in Excavation Practice.” In Enter the Past. The E-Way into the Four Dimensions of Cultural Heritage, Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology (CAA 2003), edited by K. F. Ausserer, W. Börner, M. Goriany, and L. Karlhuber-Vöckl, Vol. 1227. Oxford: Archaeopress, 276–280.
Microsoft Corporation, 2011. Microsoft Photosynth. http://photosynth.net (accessed April 1, 2008).
James Newhard. 2015. “3D Imaging in Mediterranean Archaeology: What are we doing, anyway?” In B. R. Olson and W. Caraher (eds.) Visions of Substance. 3D Imaging in Mediterranean Archaeology. University of North Dakota Press, 9–16.
Brandon R. Olson, Ryan A. Placchetti, Jamie Quartermaine, and Ann E. Killebrew. 2013. “The Tel Akko Total Archaeology Project (Akko, Israel): Assessing the Suitability of Multi-Scale 3D Field Recording in Archaeology.” Journal of Field Archaeology 38, 244–262.
Brandon R. Olson and Ryan A. Placchetti, 2015. “A Discussion of the Analytical Benefits of Image Based Modeling in Archaeology.” In B. R. Olson and W. Caraher (eds.) Visions of Substance. 3D Imaging in Mediterranean Archaeology. University of North Dakota Press, 17–26.
Rachel Opitz and Jessica Nowlin. 2012. “Photogrammetric Modeling+ GIS: Better Methods for Working with Mesh Data.” ArcUser Spring 2012, 46–49.
Rachel Opitz. 2015. “Three Dimensional Field Recording in Archaeology: An Example from Gabii.” In B. R. Olson and W. Caraher (eds.) Visions of Substance. 3D Imaging in Mediterranean Archaeology. University of North Dakota Press, 73–86.
Flaviana Oriolo and Monika Verzar-Bass, eds. 2010. Rileggere Pompei 2. L’insula 13 della Regio VI. L’Erma di Bretschneider: Rome.
Erich Pernice. 1938. Pavimente und figürliche Mosaiken. Die hellenistische Kunst in Pompeji 6. Berlin: Walter de Gruyter.
Fabrizio Pesando. 2008. “Casa di età medio-sannitica nella Regio VI: tipologia edilizia e apparati decorative.” In Pier G. Guzzo and Maria P. Guidobaldi, eds. Nuove ricerche archeologiche nell'area vesuviana (scavi 2003-2006). Atti del Convegno Internazionale, Roma 1-3 febbraio 2007. Rome: L'Erma di Bretschneider, 159-171.
Fabrizio Pesando. 2005. “Il Progetto Regio VI: le campagne di scavo 2001-2002 nelle insulae 9 e 10.” In Pier G. Guzzo and Maria P. Guidobaldi (eds.) Nuove ricerche archeologiche a Pompei ed Ercolano. Naples: Electa, 73-96.
Fabrizo Pesando and Marco Giglio, eds. 2017. Rileggere Pompei IV: L'insula 7 Della Regio IX. Rome: L'Erma Di Bretschneider.
Marc Pollefeys, Reinhard Koch, Maarten Vergauwen, Luc Van Gool. 2000. “Automated reconstruction of 3D scenes from sequences of images.” ISPRS Journal of Photogrammetry and Remote Sensing 55 (4), 251-267.
Marc Pollefeys, Luc Van Gool, Maarten Vergauwen, Kurt Cornelis, Frank Verbiest, Jan Tops. 2003. “3D recording for archaeological fieldwork. Computer Graphics and Applications.” IEEE 23 (3), 20-27.
Marc Pollefeys, Luc Van Gool, Maarten Vergauwen, Frank Verbiest, Kurt Cornelis, Jan Tops, Reinhard Koch. 2004. “Visual modeling with a hand-held camera.” International Journal of Computer Vision 59, 207-232.
Martina Polig. 2017. “3D GIS for Building Archaeology. Combining Old and New Data in a Three-dimensional Information System in the Case Study of Lund Cathedral.” SDH 1, 2, 225-238.
Adam Rabinowitz. 2015. “The Work of Archaeology in the Age of Digital Surrogacy.” In B. R. Olson and W. Caraher (eds.) Visions of Substance. 3D Imaging in Mediterranean Archaeology. University of North Dakota Press, 27–42.
Guido Ranzuglia, Marco Callieri, Matteo Dellepiane, Paolo Cignoni, and Roberto Scopigno. 2013. “MeshLab as a complete tool for the integration of photos and color with high resolution 3D geometry data.” CAA 2012 Conference Proceedings. Amsterdam: Pallas Publications - Amsterdam University Press (AUP), 406-416.
Guido Ranzuglia, Marco Callieri, Matteo Dellepiane, Paolo Cignoni, and Roberto Scopigno. 2012. “Efficient and Flexible Sampling with Blue Noise Properties of Triangular Meshes.” IEEE Trans. on Visualization and Computer Graphics 18, 6, (2012), 914-924. DOI: 10.1109/TVCG.2012.34
Christopher H. Roosevelt, Peter Cobb, Emanuel Moss, Brandon R. Olson and Sinan Ünlüsoy. 2015. “Excavation is Destruction Digitization Advances in Archaeological Practice.” Journal of Field Archaeology 40 (3), 325-346.
Annapaola Zaccaria Ruggiu and Chiara Maratini, eds. 2017. Rileggere Pompei V: L'insula 7 della Regio VI. Rome: L'Erma Di Bretschneider.
Annapaola Zaccaria Riggiu and Chiara Maratini. 2008. “Saggi e ricerche nell'insula 7 della Regio Vi, informatizzazione dei dati, GIS.” In Pier G. Guzzo and Maria P. Guidobaldi, eds. Nuove ricerche archeologiche nell'area vesuviana (scavi 2003-2006). Atti del Convegno Internazionale, Roma 1-3 febbraio 2007. Rome: L'Erma di Bretschneider, 177-188.
Sapirstein, P. 2015. “Photogrammetry as a Tool for Architectural Analysis: The Digital Architecture Project at Olympia.” In Archaeological Research in the Digital Age. Proceedings of the 1st Conference on Computer Applications and Quantitative Methods in Archaeology, Greek Chapter. Rethymno, Crete, March 6-8 2014, edited by C. Papadopoulos, Rethymno: IMS-FORTH, 129–139.
Philip Sapirstein. 2016. “Accurate Measurement with Photogrammetry at Large Sites.” Journal of Archaeological Science 66, 137–145.
Philip Sapirstein and Sarah Murray. 2017. “Establishing Best Practices for Photogrammetric Recording During Archaeological Fieldwork.” Journal of Field Archaeology 42, 337-350.
Noah Snavely, Steven M. Seitz, Richard Szeliski. 2008. Modeling the World from Internet Photo Collections. International Journal of Computer Vision 80, 2 (2008), 189–210.
Noah Snavely, Steven M. Seitz, and Richard Szeliski. 2006. Photo Tourism: Exploring image collections in 3D. ACM Transactions on Graphics. Proceedings of SIGGRAPH 2006. 835-846.
Florian Seiler, Heinz Beste, Carla Piraino, and Domenico Esposito. 2005. Le Regio VI Insula 16 e la zona della Porta Vesuvio. In Pier G. Guzzo and Maria P. Guidobaldi (eds.) Nuove ricerche archeologiche a Pompei ed Ercolano. Naples: Electa, 216-234.
Mark D. Willis, Charles W. Koenig, Stephen L. Black, and Amanda M. Castañeda. 2016. “Archaeological 3D Mapping: The Structure from Motion Revolution.” Journal of Texas Archaeology and History, vol. 3, 1-36.
Geert Verhoeven, J. J., D. Taelman, and F. Vermeulen. 2012. “Computer Vision-Based Orthophoto Mapping of Complex Archaeological Sites: The Ancient Quarry of Pitaranha (Portugal–Spain).” Archaeometry 54, 6, 1114–1129.
Geert Verhoeven. 2011. “Taking Computer Vision Aloft - Archaeological Three-Dimensional Reconstructions from Aerial Photographs with Photoscan.” Archaeol. Prospect. 18, 67-73.
Geert Verhoeven, Doneus, M., Briese, C., and Vermeulen, F. 2012. “Mapping by Matching: A Computer Vision-Based Approach to Fast and Accurate Georeferencing of Archaeological Aerial Photographs.” Journal of Archaeological Science 39, 2060-2070.
Geert Verhoeven, J. J., M. Doneus, and C. Briese. 2012a. “Computer Vision Techniques: Towards Automated Orthophoto Production.” AARGnews 44, 8-11.
Changchang Wu. 2013. “Towards Linear-time Incremental Structure From Motion.” 2013 International Conference on 3D Vision - 3DV 2013.
Changchang Wu, Sameer Agarwal, Brian Curless, and Steven M. Seitz. 2011. “Multicore Bundle Adjustment.” CVPR 2011, 3057-3064.
Sandra Zanella. 2017. « Progetto: Porta Ercolano 2012-2016 » Rivista di Studi Pompeiani 2017, p. 131-136.
Sandra Zanella, Laetitia Cavassa, Nicolas Laubry, Nicolas Monteix and Bastien Lemaire. 2016. “Pompéi, Porta Ercolano: organisation, gestion et transformations d’une zone suburbaine. Le secteur de la porte d’Herculanum à Pompéi, entre espace funéraire et commercial, Campagne 2015.” Chronique des activités archéologiques de l’École française de Rome. Les cités vésuviennes 2016.
Sandra Zanella, Laetitia Cavassa, Nicolas Laubry, Nicolas Monteix, Guilhem Chapelin, Arnaud Coutelas, Audrey Delvigne Ryrko, Mélanie Errera, Léa Gerardin, Bastien Lemaire, Raphael Macario, Florien Ortis, Vincenzo Pellegrino and Géraldine Sachau-Carcel. 2017. “Pompéi, Porta Ercolano: organisation, gestion et transformations d’une zone suburbaine, Campagne 2016.” Chronique des activités archéologiques de l’École française de Rome. Les cités vésuviennes 2017.