Navigating Ethical Challenges in a Robotics Education Program: Design Solutions at Multiple Levels

Main Article Content

Qijie Cai
Liyan Song
Scot McNary
Suzhen Duan

Abstract

This design case presents a detailed account of how we navigated various ethical issues observed in a robotics program that aimed to engage underrepresented students in robotics and STEM experience. The ethical challenges we encountered revolved around uneven participant engagement and interpersonal tensions. We tackled these challenges by designing new program elements, such as coach guides and differentiated robotics tasks. Additionally, we focused on systemic factors, aiming to reshape power dynamics by enhancing resource access, integrating the engineering design process into the curriculum, and empowering coaches to guide group activities. These design solutions were in line with the care-based ethical theory and principle-based ethics perspective, emphasizing a balanced power structure, responsiveness to individual needs and experiences, and the promotion of learner autonomy and responsibility. The redesigned program demonstrated success, evident in robust attendance, high participant satisfaction, and positive feedback from families. This design case provides practical strategies and valuable insights for educators and policymakers dedicated to promoting equity in robotics education.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

Article Details

How to Cite
Cai, Q., Song, L., McNary, S., & Duan, S. (2024). Navigating Ethical Challenges in a Robotics Education Program: Design Solutions at Multiple Levels. International Journal of Designs for Learning, 15(3), 157–168. https://doi.org/10.14434/ijdl.v15i3.37422
Section
Special Section: Ethics in Learning Design
Author Biographies

Qijie Cai, Towson University

Qijie Vicky Cai is an Associate Professor in the Department of Learning Technologies, Design, and School Library Media at Towson University. She serves as the director of the Instructional Design and Development concentration within the Master’s program in Instructional Technology. Her areas of expertise include learning experience design, robotics, and STEM education, computational thinking, and creativity

Liyan Song, Towson University

Liyan Song is a Professor in the Department of Learning Technologies, Design, and School Library Media at Towson University. She directs the Educational Technology concentration of the Instructional Technology master’s program. Her areas of expertise include distance education, action research, technology integration, and conceptual change.

Scot McNary, Towson University

Scot McNary is an Associate Professor in the Department of Learning Technologies, Design, and School Library Media at Towson University. His areas of expertise include quantitative methods, research design, and program evaluation.

Suzhen Duan, Towson University

Suzhen Duan is an Assistant Professor in the Department of Learning Technologies, Design, and School Library Media at Towson University. Her areas of expertise include positive psychology and technology integration.