Sleeping Around: The Bed from Antiquity to Now.
Annie Carlano and Bobbie Sumberg. Seattle: University of Washington
Press (co-published with Museum of International Folk Art), 2006. 200
Reviewed by Greg Stevenson
may seem like a strange thing for an academic to admit, but I often
sigh when I get asked to review a book, as so many academic books can
be a chore to read. Not so with this history of beds edited by Annie
Carlano and Bobbie Sumberg, which sits as comfortably on the university
library shelf as it does on the suburban coffee table.
Well-illustrated, well-designed, and written in a clear and concise
voice, I almost began to question if this was an academic book at all.
The good news is that you do not need to be an academic to enjoy this book or to find it engaging and useful. Sleeping Around has
been sitting around my own house for a few weeks now on the kitchen
table, and most visitors have been picking it up for a flick though. We
do, after all, spend a third of our lives in bed, so a book on beds
should be at least of some interest to everyone. I suspect, however,
that most were tempted by its titillating title. Annie Carlano asks in
the preface if the book could have been called Sleeping Around in the pre-Sex and the City
world. I would answer that it probably would not, and should not, have
been called that, then or now either. A cheeky title was not required
to make this work effective, and it is not about sex at all. But if we
can forgive it its tabloid title then this collection of chapters on
beds and their meanings was a worthwhile exercise.
is funded by grants from the International Folk Foundation, though the
material covered inside crosses over between anthropology and design
history. Flick through and you will see a good selection of
contemporary designer and mass-produced beds from the last decade. In
fact, if it has a fault then, the book is guilty of being too ambitious
with its remit. You can not really cover “The Bed from Antiquity to
Now” well in 164 pages, despite the quarto format. And do not come here
expecting to find many academic references for further reading, because
they are not here.
my opinion this book would have been better off dumping the brief tour
of early beds that was too wide-ranging and light, and concentrating
instead on, say folk bed traditions of the period 1700 to 1900. The
lack of depth is mostly felt in the second chapter, which quickly skips
from century to century and from continent to continent in an attempt
to provide an overview of bed development. The reader does gain a few
interesting tidbits of information from this—I did not know for example
that French medieval beds could be as large as 13 feet long and 11 feet
wide (4 x 3.5 meters). Apparently such large areas required long sticks
(batons de lit) to smooth out
the sheets and bedcovers. But the overall impression is that a closer
inspection of a particular theme would have been more rewarding for the
reader. Fortunately this is what the rest of the book does, and is
where the text comes into its own.
Three, on “box” and cupboard beds is a successful case study of the
practice of sleeping in enclosed spaces. Again it skips through the
different countries where such box beds are used, though with little
mention of Welsh, Scottish, or Irish box beds. This omission, however,
is levelled by the inclusion of some great illustrations of box beds
from Brittany, Sweden, and the Netherlands. It might have served better
to have considered more the meaning
of sleeping in a box bed, but the chapter was nonetheless informative
and well-constructed. The chapter ends by asking if anywhere in the
world people continue to sleep in box beds, and is doubtful if they do.
As reviewer I can add to the subject here, as I have one that is
regularly used in my West Wales cottage, the experience of which is not
as claustrophobic as the author infers.
chapter entitled “Sleeping on the Move” is, like the chapter on box
beds, the kind of subject that the reader reads out of general interest
and inquiry rather than necessarily from academic interest. It is a
fascinating subject. From the simple wool mats of Mongolian yurts to
the fancy detailing of Romany wagons or vardos,
the chapter even brings us into the modern Western world with a look at
the converted “hippie” pick-up trucks of the 1960s and 1970s.
subject of sleeping on the road is developed properly in the following
chapter that covers train berths, cruise ship cabins, airships,
airplanes, and trains. Again, fascinating images combine with a text
that lightly skips from subject to subject. Nothing is covered in
detail, but the reader has little time to get bored before moving on to
the next subject. The text is littered with interesting snippets such
as that Charles Dickens felt ‘like a giraffe being persuaded into a flowerpot’ in his cabin crossing the Atlantic in 1842.
in the Modern World” was the subject of a further chapter, and frankly
this could have been a book in itself, especially as it starts its
discussion back in the 1860s. When I saw the image of the restored
William Morris bedroom at Kelmscott Manor, I imagined that what would
follow would be a discussion on the revival of romantic notions of
historical bedrooms in the late 20th century (by designers such as
Laura Ashley, for example.). This was not the case, and the
illustration was used to discuss the Arts and Crafts original by
Morris. The chapter, though interesting, would have worked better as a
survey of contemporary beds and what they mean—and even that would be a
subject worthy of a book in itself. That does not mean that the
discussion on Yoko Ono and John Lennon’s “bed-in” at a Montreal hotel
in 1969 was not interesting (it deserved to be repeated in a book like
this), it’s just that as in many of the chapters, I felt that the
authors had given themselves too wide a brief, and had left little room
for a meaty discussion.
Beds for babies and infants gets a short chapter all to itself, and is interesting enough.
final chapter, “Sleeping Forever…and Ever” considers beds and sleeping
imagery in historical graves, and felt a little out of context in this
volume. However it is an engaging subject, and the illustrations
maintained my interest to the end. I did not even know that the root of
the word “cemetery” is the Greek for “sleeping room.”
the authors remind us, most of us are both born in and die in bed. Some
of our most pleasurable and most painful moments are experienced in
bed. Beds are undoubtedly worthy of our interest, and Sleeping Around makes for a well-illustrated and engaging introduction to the subject.
Stevenson is an Honorary Research Fellow in Archaeology and
Anthropology at the University of Wales, Lampeter. He is author of Palaces for the People: Prefabs in Post-War Britain (Batsford,
2003), and has research interests in Welsh heritage, vernacular
building heritage, vernacular furniture of Wales, and non-traditional
housing in Britain. He has recently collaborated on a television series
titled Y Ty Cymreig (‘The Welsh House’).